• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.

MT231290

Neo Member
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!
What are your thoughts about the verona sdk ps5 devkit rumours that just got revealed?
 

McHuj

Member
With the best will in the world, I can't imagine that Microsoft, after the last generation, can be technically overtaken again in all points.

Maybe the SSD is faster ok; but graphics card, memory, raytracing ??

that just seems unrealistic to me

The way I see it is that PS5 is a lot more important to Sony than Xbox is to Microsoft so Sony might go all out because they need it more.
 

vivftp

Member
Cause they don't want to leak that?

Interesting.

Welp, if Housemarque and Remedy are acquired I suppose that would give FoxyGameUK some bragging rights since he was one of the first to mention a recent acquisition and that there were multiple studios acquired.

Wait and see I suppose :)
 

01011001

Banned
The way I see it is that PS5 is a lot more important to Sony than Xbox is to Microsoft so Sony might go all out because they need it more.

that gamble could literally kill them tho. if this is true they will absolutely have the more expensive console.
and can Sony risk being more expensive?

Microsoft might even give them a double whammy and not only have a cheaper to manufacture system but also take a hit selling it, undercutting the PS5 by such a large margin that they would be dead in the water.

meanwhile I doubt Sony would sell the PS5 at a loss
 

Bogroll

Likes moldy games
From Audio to Visual, From Gamepad to Console design, PS5 will definitely be more ADVANCED!


ok
Some of the old designs are still the best, has anyone noticed the XSX is designed like a chimney stack, vents at the bottom and that flue running up to vent on the top. Creates a natural draw to get rid of unwanted air and fumes.
 

ethomaz

Banned
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!
I can believe in that truth.
I’m biased.
 

bitbydeath

Member
that gamble could literally kill them tho. if this is true they will absolutely have the more expensive console.
and can Sony risk being more expensive?

Microsoft might even give them a double whammy and not only have a cheaper to manufacture system but also take a hit selling it, undercutting the PS5 by such a large margin that they would be dead in the water.

meanwhile I doubt Sony would sell the PS5 at a loss

Sony are a multi-billion dollar company, they can certainly afford it.
 

McHuj

Member
meanwhile I doubt Sony would sell the PS5 at a loss

I can see it go either way. I think it really depends on how quickly the costs can come down. Cost aren't static. Do they need to sell 5 or 50 million consoles before costs drop? If the loses are limited to the first release year, I can see them selling at a loss. That first year of sales will probably be only ~8-10% of the life time sales.
 

Ruben43cb

Member
Be surprising if MS with all their resources comes in less powerful in the TF game. Might as well sign the game over papers for their console. They will always rock PC etc but if the xbox doesnt bring the ooomph like my one X , then I wont get it. And I've always had a xbox and PS console together. Would build a nice 20TF+ gaming PC when the behemoth cards come out late 2020/2021
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Banned
Be surprising if MS with all their resources comes in less powerful in the TF game. Might as well sign the game over papers for their console. They will always rock PC etc but if the xbox doesnt bring the ooomph like my one X , then I wont get it. And I've always had a xbox and PS console together.
But they are already moving from consoles...
 

Ellery

Member
I think it's time for both sides to temper expectations... expect lower Tflops.
I think it is more likely to be about 10 in RDNA flops and 12 in GCN flops.


People need to stop thinking in RDNA and GCN TFLOPS. (I had hopes that it would have died down by now, because it was rampant after Navi was released)

There are only TFLOPs. There is a way to calculate TFLOPs and that doesn't change with different architectures. Yes I am well aware that a 10TF RDNA card is faster in games than a 10TF GCN card, but that doesn't mean XX RDNA TF is like YY GCN TF.

It was clear for a very long time now that both next gen consoles are using Navi, well before Navi was released and calculating in GCN TFLOPs is doing nobody a favor right now.

Neither Microsoft nor Sony is going to use GCN TFLOPs in any of their advertisment or specification announcements.

Talking about GCN TFLOPs is mostly used because people who predict extremely high TFLOPs for next gen consoles can fool themselves into believing they were right when they still think it is going to be something absurd like 14TF.

Sorry if this sounds a bit annoying and like I have a stick up my b***, but all predictions and guesses are counted in RDNA TFLOPs.
 

R600

Banned
everyone unverified that posts insider info should immediately be banned imo.

this is just annoying to be honest.
even the "trusted" leakers don't agree, so it doesn't help when anyone can just jump on here posting vague shit to stirr things up.
Why is that? You can see how much completely unverified shit gets upvoted here. Last time Tommy boy posted specs he got a bit to carried away and posted L1 data that can only work with GCN cards, and not with Navis.

I see he learned to be a bit more vague so posting "XSX>PS5 in dev kit noise department" is a new bullet point.

In any case.

AMDs official internal testing data that gets purged of internet > bad

Vague insiders with completely unrealistic specs > good
 
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!

If that is true, will Microsoft have sufficient time or the ability to increase the specs of Xlauncher to:
a) be at 5% differnce
b) be neck to neck with PS5
c) be somewhat to significantly better than PS5?
 
But they've been kind of playing into that power narrative for building goodwill for next-gen and many places have been reporting 12TF Navi. That no one at MS has come out to dismiss this, given the messaging of transparency they seem to be going for these days, would be very damaging to them if they weren't at least very near that stated number.

The time to retract/renege on those claims passed by mid-December, but I don't think they're so stupid as to ride on that type of perception in a power narrative knowing they'd be well off-base from that. All the same, there's a big possibility Sony are not talking those type of performance metrics precisely because they wouldn't want to build up an impression that they could possibly falter on delivering on and thus betraying goodwill in the process.

The fact that they used vague multipliers to begin with are a pretty big giveaway. 12TFs is actually FAAAAR beyond everyone's most realistic expectations, so there's no reason not to sing it from the rooftops if it was true.

MS just as easily can be not correcting folks, because they aren't ready to talk specific detailed hardware specs yet; which was obvious by them using ambiguous multipliers in the first place.

I am more or less in this boat too. The wording in the 2x jump could be interpreted two ways, and I'm leaning towards it being a 2x jump in real world performance from the GPU. Meaning of course, that the jump is less than 2x in the raw TFLOP figure.

That said, we have had numerous 'insiders' telling us it's 12tf NAVI, both consoles are super powerful etc. I'm happy if I'm wrong, but I think expectations are a little high based on what has actually been revealed from MS/Sony.

All insiders afaik, are referencing internal MS sources. So the easy explanation is that these insiders have been told the same 2x XB1X and 8x XB1S multipliers that MS themselves told us; and the insiders have "done the math" and in doing so assumed raw TFLOPs.

AFIAK, no developer or leaker referencing a developer source has come out yet to leak the exact 12 TFs firgure for XSX. And I wouldn't necessarily blame them, since even devs may be wondering over MS's multiplier PR statements about the potential for a suprise clockspeed increase to 12TF prior to final reveal (it happened last gen transition).
 

Darklor01

Might need to stop sniffing glue
I’m starting to suspect the insiders only know we’re close to the reveal of the PlayStation 5, however, maybe, a date/week range hasn’t been locked down leading them to be vague about when it’s happening,
 

vivftp

Member
Hum aquired the ip of Alan Wake in july 2019...and before that publishing mobile game and release control on ps4. They have certainly taking steps away from Microsoft.. But enough to be bought?..

Remedy and Sony have certainly become closer with visits to one anothers studios and a fair amount of social media interaction. Insiders on Era did indicate Sony was exploring options for acquisition mid to late last year, but it's anyones guess on what happened there.

IIRC we also had a person at Remedy like a twitter post by Foxy (or was it Tidux?) when they posted about a new Sony acquisition. So I guess there's some smoke there. Only time will tell if there's fire.
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
Is this Tommy Fisher guy gonna get verified?

He went to mods, showed them material buttttt didn't want to give up source. Mod of War told us as much and stated he didn't get banned bcus it was neither proven he was or wasn't an insider.

My take he has sources, info looked legit but he didn't want to give up sources or show more. I kinda believe Tommy.
 
Last edited:
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!
XSX: 16GB GDDR6
PS5: 18GB GDDR6 + 4GB DDR4
SSD: 2.3GB/S x 5GB/s

These are genuinely my guesses. Also according to our own Osiris, PS5 devkit is insanely loud and PS5's RT solution is indeed better than XSX's.
 
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!

If this is confirmed it will be brutal and at the same time terrible for MS. It will be fun. And you will have earned the respect of many people. Thanks for the info.
 
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!

I don't know what's sadder; that you were warned to provide verification multiple times and failed to do so (and warned to stop presenting yourself as an insider), or that you've duped a nice pocket of people to buy into your character.
 

bitbydeath

Member
XSX: 16GB GDDR6
PS5: 18GB GDDR6 + 4GB DDR4
SSD: 2.3GB/S x 5GB/s

These are genuinely my guesses. Also according to our own Osiris, PS5 devkit is insanely loud and PS5's RT solution is indeed better than XSX's.

I was trying to work out how to read that line given it reads like XSX is louder than PS5, but I’m guessing he intended it as the opposite.

So PS5 noise is louder than XSX which would fall in line with Osiris.
 
Last edited:

Bryank75

Banned
I was trying to work out how to read that line given it reads like XSX is louder than PS5, but I’m guessing he intended it as the opposite.

So PS5 noise is louder than XSX which would fall in line with Osiris.
I wonder if Sony having a movie subsidiary helped in any way with developing the ray tracing solution!?
 

01011001

Banned

oh damn, they went public in 2017? didn't know that.

so ok then, that makes absolutely zero sense then right?

how secret can you be about taking over a publicly traded company?

like that's the nail in tje coffin for this guy's "leaks" then... fucking honestly, ban him from the thread at this point if he does say another word without getting verification.

I also saw that he had another oopsie with tech data that made zero sense apparently
 
Last edited:

Rossco EZ

Member
is there anyway that a member of staff could re enter discussion with tommy about his info? maybe he has something new now that can pass him as verified without fully disclosing his source etc.. (not sure on the exact process) if not that’s fine. it’s a good indication that something he showed or discussed must hold some credence as he wasn’t banned first time he started posting.
 

Disco_

Member
At least on hard data that's been provided out there (photo evidence, expert analysis and GPU testing benchmarks), the only way XSX would hit below 10TF Navi on a 56CU core would be if the clocks are set below 1400MHz...which in that case, why even go for a tower design? A more traditional system design would be more than adequate. Either that, or they've disabled something like 12CUs which...why go for a die over 400mm2 in the first place?

A big box with plenty of room where you don't have to design each piece to fit like tetris pieces is probably cheaper than a smaller box where things are tailored to fit perfectly together. If the dev kit leak is any indication, that's all it could be. Head over to b3d where people are showing concern over the rear intake and possible air flow issues. "tower design"=/=automatically better.

Keep in mind those guys aren't idiots like most of us here. They actually know what they're talking about.

Some of the old designs are still the best, has anyone noticed the XSX is designed like a chimney stack, vents at the bottom and that flue running up to vent on the top. Creates a natural draw to get rid of unwanted air and fumes.
On such a small scale, 12" height, stack effect isn't a thing.
 
Just need to remind you things that i said before for the last time\
GPU: PS5>SeX ~10%
RayTracing Accelerators: PS5>X1 (PS5's RT works by using acceleration structures and algorithms much like nVidia's RTX cores)
CPU: Sex>PS5 ~ 6%
Memory: PS5>Sex for the size and bandwidth
SSD: PS5>Sex ~ Over twice as fast (this is the biggest and most noticable difference)
Fan noise (Dev-Kit): Sex>PS5 (not as egregious 1x vs. Pro).

BTW it's up to you believe me or not, but things gonna be clear very soon and you will find out who knows and who knows shit.

Bonus?
Remedy and Housemarque have been in Sony's WWS family for a while now!

Techland belongs to MS now!

I'll give you one thing. Your confidence is inspiring.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom