• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of Thrones *Tagged Book Spoilers, Please Read OP* |OT| Season 3 - Sundays on HBO

Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lonestar

I joined for Erin Brockovich discussion
as someone who has read bits and pieces of the books and wiki's (because I'm impatient and weak :p) could the most recent turn of events at Crastor's, mean ASOS
Coldhands could be showing up in the next couple of episodes? Seeing that he helps Sam and Gilly escape after the mutiny at Crastor's. I want to see what he might look like on film, and if it'd be easier to tell who he might have been
 
D

Dany

Banned
1. Robb Stark
2. Joer Mormont
3. Gendry
4. Renly









5. Jon Snow


tumblr_mlo0d40hU61qeip53o1_400.gif
 
S

Steelyuhas

Member
Eidan said:
I just started thinking. With the alleged confusion about who Barristan Selmy and Beric Dondarrion are.

ASOS
Are audiences aware of Kevan? Do they even know he's Tywin's brother? I'm not sure if the actor will even show up this season, but he should pop in during Tyrion's trial.
Click to expand...

Series
No, I don't think they do (Kevan was actually in episode 8 of season 2!), but that said he will be easy to reintroduce him. "Hey remember, this is Tywin's brother? Yay if you do remember, if you don't, it's Tywin's brother, he will now have significance."
fallengorn said:
xE0WXg8.jpg
Click to expand...

lol

-------------------

Q & A with Cogman is very interesting, some nice tidbits in there, very excited for his episode this week.

---------------------------------------

No Onna in your lists? You people should be ashamed!
 
L

Latvian Hitman

Member
Burt said:
Not really relevant at the moment, but how have they gone through 2 castings of Gregor Clegaine and neither of them are Robert Maillet?


Dude is 7 feet tall and has an awesome angry face.

Could totally see him (can't remember which book but don't read this if you haven't been through 'em)
rocking a greatsword with one hand
Click to expand...

I thought Conan Stevens was great in season one- it was too bad he got so busy with other projects. Ian White wasn't an ideal replacement, IMO. I agree with you that Robert Maillet could have been really good.
 
T

tino

Banned
Yonafunu said:
Tino deserves the best tag ever. Seriously.
Click to expand...

You make me sound like I am tag fishing. I completely stand behind my viewpoints. If you guys want to bring out the arguments, you can bring out the arguments. Don't attack me personally. I am above that.

I will go on and on why Margaery Tyrell should be a younger character and played by a a younger looking actress.

As far as the ugliness of Natalie Dormer, its a separated topic. I am just saying if HBO can get Julius Caecar to play Mance Rayder, they can cast the Margaery Tyrell character properly if they want to.
 
J

Jobiensis

Member
-griffy- said:
There should be no confusion about why Cat brought Tyrion to the Vale instead of Winterfell, only confusion about why she arrested/kidnapped Tyrion with so little real evidence in the first place.
Click to expand...

I don't really like Cat, but she 'arrested' Tyrion because she didn't want it known that she went to King's landing. Once Tyrion saw her, it wouldn't be surprising if he figures she knows he did it. Pretty much self preservation, and in some respect to keep her family in KL safe. Tyrion tried to have Bran killed, he wouldn't have a problem having her or others in her family killed. Remember she was just with Rodrick and she tried to stay unnoticed and hidden. Only when she was discovered by Tyrion did she arrest him.

ASOS:
Her actions basically cause the slaughter of a bunch of Stark men including Ned getting speared (or in the book Ned body slammed by a horse), but if Tyrion did it it would have been a smart maneuver. Only problem is Tyrion didn't do it.
 
N

Neffarias_Bredd

Member
tino said:
You make me sound like I am tag fishing. I completely stand behind my viewpoints. If you guys want to bring out the arguments, you can bring out the arguments. Don't attack me personally. I am above that.

I will go on and on why Margaery Tyrell should be a younger character and played by a a younger looking actress.

As far as the ugliness of Natalie Dormer, its a separated topic. I am just saying if HBO can get Julius Caecar to play Mance Rayder, they can cast the Margaery Tyrell character properly if they want to.
Click to expand...

But Ciarán Hinds was horrible casting for Mance Rayder
 
D

Dysun

Member
Hinds fits Mance Rayder less than Dorner fits Margaery.
And it's not even close

This sentiment that she is too old to be Margaery is borderline incomprehensible when every other character on the show has also been aged-up. You dont like her fine, but dont make it out like she is miscast. Her character in the books is barely a background character, and they are trying to bring more life into the role.
 
Lactose_Intolerant

Lactose_Intolerant

Member
aceface said:
Read an interview with Bryan Cogman today with some interesting stuff:



So it looks like they will be going to unpublished material with GRRM's guidance, which is really the best way to go about it. It's weird that the show will be the place we get new revelations for awhile though.

Interview here: http://winteriscoming.net/2013/04/a...ing-process-robb-and-talisa-and-renlys-peach/
Click to expand...

Or they need to know who are actual characters they need to cast and who they can cut/kill off.

On a seperate note, Jon's storyline for the show has been horribly written.
 
N

Neffarias_Bredd

Member
Discotheque said:
No he wasn't, it's the showrunners' fault that he's so stoic in the series. He's not a bad actor, and he's being told what to do
Click to expand...

I never said he was a bad actor, I just don't think he's right for the character. I can't comment on whether his portrayal is due to the showrunner's direction or because that's how he interprets the character, as I'm not there on set.

I hope I'm proven wrong in later episodes, by the way
 
D

Discotheque

Banned
The lines he's being given dont seem to allow him the interpretation of being more light hearted

He's had like 3 scenes so far and they're all playing the hard ass.
 
E

Eidan

Member
Why do people think Mance wasn't a hard ass? He seemed that way in the book. Is it because he plays music in the book?
 
N

Neffarias_Bredd

Member
Eidan said:
Why do people think Mance wasn't a hard ass? He seemed that way in the book. Is it because he plays music in the book?
Click to expand...

I don't think it has to do with him being a hard ass, in the books Mance seems more charismatic and almost mischievous. Even the way he's introduced in the book seems to suggest that he's less of a commander and more of a personality almost. He's not the typical stoic king.

Probably has a lot to do with his story about sneaking in to Winterfell, which so far has been left out of the show.
 
E

Eidan

Member
CracknutWhirrun said:
I don't think it has to do with him being a hard ass, in the books Mance seems more charismatic and almost mischievous
Click to expand...

Eh, ASOS
I remember Jon's interactions with Mance being pretty limited in the book. Every time they spoke it was essentially Mance telling him "I don't really trust you, crow. If you're betraying me I'll kill you". Nothing about Hinds' portrayal seems out of character.
 
N

Neffarias_Bredd

Member
Eidan said:
Eh, ASOS
I remember Jon's interactions with Mance being pretty limited in the book. Every time they spoke it was essentially Mance telling him "I don't really trust you, crow. If you're betraying me I'll kill you". Nothing about Hinds' portrayal seems out of character.
Click to expand...

I can't look through the book as I don't have it with me at the moment, but I've read it a couple of times and I never got the feeling that Mance was some serious hard ass. To each his own.
 
M

Mario007

Member
Dysun said:
Hinds fits Mance Rayder less than Dorner fits Margaery.
And it's not even close

This sentiment that she is too old to be Margaery is borderline incomprehensible when every other character on the show has also been aged-up. You dont like her fine, but dont make it out like she is miscast. Her character in the books is barely a background character, and they are trying to bring more life into the role.
Click to expand...
Well that scene with Joeffry last episode was kinda disturbing to watch, considering how young the dude playing Joeffry looks. Still I like Margaery and am glad the way her character is shaping up.

Pity to hear she's not as big in the books.
 
A

Al-ibn Kermit

Junior Member
tino said:
You make me sound like I am tag fishing. I completely stand behind my viewpoints. If you guys want to bring out the arguments, you can bring out the arguments. Don't attack me personally. I am above that.

I will go on and on why Margaery Tyrell should be a younger character and played by a a younger looking actress.

As far as the ugliness of Natalie Dormer, its a separated topic. I am just saying if HBO can get Julius Caecar to play Mance Rayder, they can cast the Margaery Tyrell character properly if they want to.
Click to expand...

The female characters like Sansa, Daenerys, etc are meant to be in their mid-teens when the series starts. But if you plan to show any nudity, then obviously you need an "older" actor.

As for your opinion on how poorly cast she is, by any objective standard she is very pretty. Unique, but pretty. I'm guessing you just got a little upset that the actor looks different than how you imagined the character but if she smiled at you in public you'd be a blushing, pants-jizzing mess.
 
T

torontoml

Member
Is there specific mods we should inform about spoilers in the non book thread? Or just anyone that's online.

Edit: Apparently it's speculation
 
L

Latvian Hitman

Member
tino said:
I will go on and on why Margaery Tyrell should be a younger character and played by a a younger looking actress.

As far as the ugliness of Natalie Dormer, its a separated topic. I am just saying if HBO can get Julius Caecar to play Mance Rayder, they can cast the Margaery Tyrell character properly if they want to.
Click to expand...

Looks to me like Dormer's portrayal of Margaery has made for one of the more popular recent additions to the series among people here. Along with your judgment of her physical appearance, it would appear you're thrashing about on the edge of a limb by yourself here.

Hey- power to ya'. Thrash away.
 
M

Morrigan Stark

Arrogant Smirk
Shit, just got that PM. Sorry about the lack of spoiler tags. I'm usually very careful about that.

Is there any reason why we need to tag the book spoilers though? The non-readers have their threads, why can't we use this one to talk about the book stuff more freely?

Again, I'm very sorry if anyone got spoiled. It won't happen again. ;_;
 
T

Trasher

Member
Morrigan Targaryen said:
Shit, just got that PM. Sorry about the lack of spoiler tags. I'm usually very careful about that.

Is there any reason why we need to tag the book spoilers though? The non-readers have their threads, why can't we use this one to talk about the book stuff more freely?

Again, I'm very sorry if anyone got spoiled. It won't happen again. ;_;
Click to expand...

That's what this is for.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=433233

Would be redundant to do another thread.

I agree though, it's kind of annoying having so many threads. =/
 
T

The Anti-Monitor

Banned
Solo said:
First Brie > ScarJo and now this? My goodness. Twice we've agreed on ladies this week, Anti. Sign of the apocalypse?
Click to expand...
I never said Brie > ScarJo, I said maybe, nowadays.

And Margaery might not have a typical look but I can't understand someone not finding her attractive.

Best looking are still Ygritte and Missandei

Morrigan Targaryen said:
Shit, just got that PM. Sorry about the lack of spoiler tags. I'm usually very careful about that.

Is there any reason why we need to tag the book spoilers though? The non-readers have their threads, why can't we use this one to talk about the book stuff more freely?

Again, I'm very sorry if anyone got spoiled. It won't happen again. ;_;
Click to expand...

As strange as it might sound, some of us here have read the 3rd book but not all of them. That particular spoiler was for book 3, but who knows?
 
Z

Zabka

Member
Morrigan Targaryen said:
Shit, just got that PM. Sorry about the lack of spoiler tags. I'm usually very careful about that.

Is there any reason why we need to tag the book spoilers though? The non-readers have their threads, why can't we use this one to talk about the book stuff more freely?

Again, I'm very sorry if anyone got spoiled. It won't happen again. ;_;
Click to expand...

I think originally there was a tagged spoilers thread to accommodate people who hadn't read all the books. The further we get along the less I feel it's necessary though.
 
M

Morrigan Stark

Arrogant Smirk
fallengorn said:
[Renly pic]
Click to expand...
LOL

Raist said:
I'm not sure how you can defend
- Running off to KL, leaving her kids alone, just to deliver a message to her husband
- Capturing Tyrion and dragging him to the Eyrie (not Winterfell, wtf?)
- Trusting the slimy Littlefinger
- Leaving Jamie go

As being good decisions. She's just a frustrated, jealous, superstitious god botherer who doesn't bother to stop and think for a second before doing stuff with huge implications. Catelyn Tully sucks.
Click to expand...
Sigh. I, and others, have already explained all of that. It's like talking to a brick wall, I guess.

Dany M said:
1. Robb Stark
2. Joer Mormont
3. Gendry
4. Renly


5. Jon Snow
Click to expand...
Ewww Renly doesn't belong there.
Also, did you mean Jorah? Jeor is the Old Bear. xD Not that there's anything wrong with being into grandfathers, but... yeah. ;)
Btw:
1. Jaime Lannister
2. Jaqen H'ghar
3. Ned Stark

It is known.

Trasher said:
That's what this is for.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=433233

Would be redundant to do another thread.

I agree though, it's kind of annoying having so many threads. =/
Click to expand...

This thread is about the book series, not the show. I was thinking that we should have the no-book-spoiler thread, and a TV thread for book readers, where we can discuss the book stuff more freely. Is there any non-reader who actually hangs out in this thread?

(I'm not trying to justify my lack of tags, by the way, this was completely my mistake and it won't happen again I swear ^^. I just wish it weren't necessary to use the tags here.)

Edit:
The Anti-Monitor said:
As strange as it might sound, some of us here have read the 3rd book but not all of them. That particular spoiler was for book 3, but who knows?
Click to expand...

That is indeed strange! What are you waiting for! Read them!

... Ok, that makes sense. Thanks.
 
S

Solo

Member
Hystzen said:
I still wish the dream of Stannis being played by Mark Strong


Also come on guys no love for the Red Priestess Melisandre (Carice Van Houten)she up in top 5 easily
Click to expand...

To expand to 5:

1. Nathalie Emmanuel
2. Emilia Clarke
3. Natalie Dormer
4. Carice Van Houen
5. Oona Chaplin
 
T

Trasher

Member
Morrigan Targaryen said:
This thread is about the book series, not the show. I was thinking that we should have the no-book-spoiler thread, and a TV thread for book readers, where we can discuss the book stuff more freely. Is there any non-reader who actually hangs out in this thread?

(I'm not trying to justify my lack of tags, by the way, this was completely my mistake and it won't happen again I swear ^^. I just wish it weren't necessary to use the tags here.)

Edit:


That is indeed strange! What are you waiting for! Read them!

... Ok, that makes sense. Thanks.
Click to expand...

Except the thread is called "Game of Thrones"...lol. That's the name of the show. Hence the following statement of "Tagged Book Spoilers" that immediately follows the show's name in the thread title.

And there has been at least a couple people mention that they only watch the show, but prefer reading this thread to the other one. Don't ask me why, but that's what they've said haha.
 
M

Morrigan Stark

Arrogant Smirk
The Anti-Monitor said:
Insta-void without Khal Drogo.

Drogo > Jaime > Jaqen > Robb > Ned.

Indeed.
Click to expand...

No way. Drogo had silly eye make-up and ugly-ass hair (and an ugly beard too). Jason Momoa looked sexier as Conan than as Drogo. And Robb's one of those pretty boys. I don't know why every girl's swooning over him, he does nothing for me (neither does Jon).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

'3 Body Problem' Renewed for Season 2 at Netflix
News
45
4K
What A Shame... replied
Game Of Thrones Fan Completes GRRM's Final 2 Books Using AI Since 12 Year Wait Is Ongoing
13
3K
DKehoe replied
George R.R. Martin flew to New York to 'beg' an HBO executive to make 'Game of Thrones' 10 seasons long, according to his agent
2 3
105
8K
Kenpachii replied
Coming to Game Pass: Call of Duty: Black Ops 6, Dead Island, StarCraft & StarCraft II, and More
News Platform 2
88
4K
Elitro replied
"House of the Dragon" FULL SHOW AND BOOK SPOILER thread!
2
79
9K
jason10mm replied
Top Bottom