2016 was a really odd year for me. Usually I trend towards picking up most of the large "direct-to-consumer (D2C)" sets, and those end up making the bulk of my "Best of the Year" lists. However this year I found myself feeling ambivalent about most of the D2C set reveals, and ended up picking up only a fraction of them. The silver lining was that I focused more on the smaller sets, and cemented my affection for a certain theme.
10. 70316 Jestro's Evil Mobile
Truth be told, Nexo Knights did not blow me away as the new "Action" theme for 2016. I did find a few gems in this theme however, and my favorite of these is Evil Mobile. The brick-built giant Sparkks, pulling a diabolical massive chariot, the awesome steed Lance's robo-horse, and the titular characters Jestro and the Book of Monsters combined to make this a fun set to both build and play.
9. 31044 Park Animals
My first set of 2016 outlasts many others to make the list. LEGO has been killing it for several years with their CREATOR animal sets, and 31044 may be the best one yet. The dog and duck are adorable, the ducklings clever, and the alt-builds are solid. This one will be on display for years to come.
8. 76051 Super Hero Airport Battle
The ultimate Avenger vs Avenger battle in Civil War is captured in this set to great effect. Make no mistake though, this set would not have made this list if not for the brick-built Giant-Man fig. With a much greater scale and improved posability over the previous bigfigs, the Giant-Man fig is a great new addition that will likely be repeated in future sets. The Quinjet is "okay", but suffers in comparison to previous versions, and the airport tower is uninspiring. Bonus points for the Ant-Man microfig though.
7. 60134 Fun in the park - City People Pack
This set is an important development in several ways. First, it includes the debut of a wheelchair-bound minifig, a great addition to LEGO's diversity. Second, it marks the debut of the new baby minifig, which has been desired for a long time. Third, this is a CITY pack that is only minifigs and some small associated builds to flesh out one's city build. No policemen, firemen, or vehicles make this a refreshing change for LEGO.
6. 75153 AT-ST Walker
With the debut of Rogue One less than a week away, this set represents the best of an extremely solid initial wave of sets for this subtheme. It's been a while since we had a proper AT-ST, and this build is a much improved representation than the previous AT-ST that came with the Endor Bunker set from 2009.
5. 31052 Vacation Getaways
The premiere CREATOR set for 2016 features an amazing main-build, with two almost-as-great alt-builds that makes me want to buy three copies of this set. The camper is a superior CITY-scale vehicle, complete with a curious bear. The alt sets are a house that is another great addition to the CREATOR houses subtheme, and could be a main build set in its own right. The boat is one of the best CITY-style crafts since the theme's inception. I can't say enough about how awesome this set is.
4. 75140 Resistance Troop Transporter
At the start of this year, looking ahead at the leaked Star Wars sets, I never expected this set to become on of my favorite sets of the year. This set only had a minute or so of screentime in the Force Awakens, and took a back seat to ships like the Falcon, Kylo Ren's Shuttle, Poe's X-Wing, and the new FO TIE Fighters. Once I started building these sets, I learned the hidden truth - this set is full of advanced building techniques and additional touches that were not necessary, but add up to create a great interpretation of this ship.
3. 10251 Brick Bank
A Jamie Berard modular building only makes the 3rd spot? The truth is, the solid competition this year, combined with the revitalization of the modular building subtheme over the last several years, result in a solid modular not reaching the top spot. There is nothing wrong with this set, and it is a great addition to my modular row, but it also doesn't stand out greatly from the rest of the modular sets, and does not reach the heights of the Parisian Restaurant in brilliance.A solid addition to a cornerstone theme.
2. 10252 Volkswagen Beetle
Full stop - this is the best "advanced-build vehicle" released by LEGO to-date. As Phon mentioned in his list, the Beetle was designed by Mike Psiaki, who also created another set in this top ten - Vacation Getaways. Pisaki has built a marvel here, capturing the curves of the Beetle with the assistance of some new elements, in a huge improvement over the previous Beetle. Everything is scaled superbly, adding up to an excellent display piece for both hardcore and casual LEGO fans alike. This is the "Parisian Restaurant" of the advanced vehicle subtheme, and will be tough to beat in future additions.
1. 76057 Spider-Man: Web Warriors Ultimate Bridge Battle
Disclosure - I am a huge fan of "classic" Spider-Man - I grew up reading "Amazing Spider-Man", and it was my favorite comic for almost a decade. This set encapsulates a scenario which fit in perfectly with the stories of that time, and includes a trio of classic Spider-Man villains which I have been waiting for. The bridge is both an excellent display piece, and a multi-featured playset, and is one of those rare sets where the negatives are hard to come up with. I fell in love with this set when it was initially revealed at Toy Fair, and the reality lived up to the promise. I am happy to present the Bridge Battle as my set of the year.
Let's be frank - it can be argued that CREATOR has been "theme of the year" for the last several years at least. This theme has been the dependable stalwart of quality sets, containing excellent builds. It is also one of the few themes with official "alt builds", and a comparably reasonable price point, making most sets in this theme an excellent value.
5002946 Silver Centurion
A classic Iron Man armor from the 80's makes its LEGO debut, with a highly-detailed representation of one of my favorite armors. The only downside is that it was a videogame preorder bonus, making it expensive to acquire.
71013 Hiker
A new exclusive backpack, compass and map add to a great looking CMF.
My Top Sets of 2015
My Top Sets of 2014
My Top Sets of 2013
My Top Sets of 2012