Pretty sure I'm almost done with Alan's campaign, but I had to cut it short just now because the sun has risen IRL and it just feels wrong making my way through The Dark Place while the sun is shining outside. I'm weird, I know. I'll finish it tonight.
My thoughts so far: Narratively, this game is a 10/10. It's the culmination of everything Remedy has done over the years and it's quite glorious.
But from a gameplay standpoint, it very much feels like the studio's first attempt at survival horror. I'm not pretending to be an all-knowing arbiter of survival horror, but I have played quite a lot of them, and it's clear that there is room for improvement. One example off the top of my head is that the dynamic difficulty is far too generous, even on Hard difficulty - I'm at the point where I don't open containers anymore because my inventory and shoeboxes are overflowing lol
Still loving it overall though.