Support NeoGAF

[Trilobit]

Ditch everything that has traces of the sequel trilogy and make it take place over 100 years after RotJ. I have no interest in anything with Rey.

 

[INC]

Just start over with knights of the old Republic

 

[Kvally]

Star Wars just keeps getting worse and worse with every new movie.

At least episodes 7-9 were better than 1-3.

 

[winjer]

At least episodes 7-9 were better than 1-3.

Episode 1 was terrible and very boring, to the exception of the Darth Maul fight. Episode 2 and 3 were significantly better, though far from the quality set by the original trilogy.
But episodes 7-9were dog shit. A complete disgrace to the franchise.

 

[LordCBH]

Just start over with knights of the old Republic

And watch Disney and Kathleen completely fuck that story up?

 

[March Climber]

I like how the post that bumped this almost-year old thread asks 'who gives a shit?'

 

[Kvally]

Episode 1 was terrible and very boring, to the exception of the Darth Maul fight. Episode 2 and 3 were significantly better, though far from the quality set by the original trilogy.
But episodes 7-9were dog shit. A complete disgrace to the franchise.

Have to completely disagree. If we could pretend 1-3 never happened and do them over from scratch, it wouldn’t be soon enough.

 

[Vyse]

I like how the post that bumped this almost-year old thread asks 'who gives a shit?'

It’s what we do.

 

[thefool]

Sell.
That's actually the way out.

 

[INC]

And watch Disney and Kathleen completely fuck that story up?

She'll be gone soon

 

[Badlucktroll]

why dont they do some young palpatine and darth plagus stuff

 

[Clear]

She'll be gone soon

Too late. Franchise is never going to be what it was.

The days of sticking the Star Wars logo on stuff and it automatically shifting in vast quantities is over.

 

[Yoda]

Yeah sadly this (my former favorite) franchise is just done. Half a decade ago I'd have been annoyed, now? Really doesn't phase me at all. Haven't "consumed" any Star Wars in years, to illustrate how much of a super fan I used to be... I can recite the lines of the original trilogy from memory.

 

[AJUMP23]

You know your cooked when Yoda is done with Star Wars.

 

[violence]

Another thing for me to pretend doesn't exist.

 

[RCX]

There are 3 Star Wars movies

Only 3

 

[clarky]

Have to completely disagree. If we could pretend 1-3 never happened and do them over from scratch, it wouldn’t be soon enough.

1-3 were bad. 7 was better than the prequels but only just. 8 and 9 completely killed the franchise for me. 8 completely shat on luke's character and 9 well, my god what a steaming turd that was.

 

[clarky]

There are 3 Star Wars movies

Only 3

4 for me, I enjoyed Rogue one.

 

[Shadowplay1979]

If the movie is 10 minutes long and is just luke waking up the night after the death star explodes and every film and show made aftr 1983 has just been a fucked up fever dream he had from ewok food....i would pay to see it.

 

[Shadowplay1979]

Disneys made nothing but ass discharge but not gonna pretend that 1-3 wasnt also horrible terribly written , contrived trash which shit on the legacy and magic of the original. The moment you fucked up episode 1 you fucked up everything after....its basically 3 gold bars sitting on a stack of soggy cardboard. When you make the base garbage, everything that comes after forever has to balance on that. And now disney went and shoveled piles of shit on top of that.

Ep 4-6 is cannon....the only other cannon stories are whats in my mind based off of whats talked about in those non special edition stories. The movies created by Lucas............... Marcia Lucas.

 

[Kvally]

1-3 were bad. 7 was better than the prequels but only just. 8 and 9 completely killed the franchise for me. 8 completely shat on luke's character and 9 well, my god what a steaming turd that was.

I agree Luke was shat on. But Anakin/Darth Vader was played by such a douche. Hayden made me want to gag. That was deflating to watch.