• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.

FranXico

Member
If Sony were more powerful you would think that they would of reacted some way to the 12tf news from Phil. Why let Xbox bask in its 12tf glory? It would of been a megaton if Sony tweeted "13.2TFLOPS" after the Spencer article. It is odd and not like Sony, Sony like to react quite dynamnicly.
"Sony" and "dynamic" do not belong in the same sentence LOL. They have a track record of being too slow to react.
 

Sosokrates

Report me if I continue to console war
"Sony" and "dynamic" do not belong in the same sentence LOL. They have a track record of being too slow to react.

They were quite quick taking advantage of the Xbox one mishaps at the start of this gen.
No way was jack trettons used games/always online speech was not changed based on what ms said.
 

Null_Key

Neo Member
Imagine you are buying a gaming PC off Newegg. Two models to choose from, both around $2000. Which one do you buy and why?
I agree its a choice, a 2000 dollar laptops for the most part will have similarities in specs and design at a given price. For example if you got a 2000 gaming laptop and say it has a 2070 RTX, most likely whether it be a MSI, ASUS, ACER, it will really come down to minor tweaks and preference, unless over course you are individuals that enjoy paying a premium like Razer. PC though typically operate will alittle more leg room for manufacturers than console because they require a higher profit margin in order to maintain a business, while consoles rely mostly on royalties from software and GAAS platform for profitability. I enjoy both systems and while I play lean toward Playstation due to friends and the games that it have(huge fan of Persona), I also have Xbox One X because there are plenty of games I don't want to miss such as Forza and Gears. I think it's a really exciting time to be gamers, but this need for specs superiority is absurd, if you want specs, go buy 64 core desktop AMD EPYC Processor and SLI a crap ton of Titan x.
 

rntongo

Banned
I'm right here?

I was just clarifying for him what the files are or are not. I'm not sure what is incorrect about what I said? The GH tests were not exclusively Ariel/Oberon BC tests. Those were cases in the units.

From the beginning, I've held that I believe PS5 will be 40CU at 2GHZ (10.2) with the below PowerVR RT built in. This would let the APU punch above its TF weight as unlike XSX you aren't relying on the full 12TF to do the RT.

https://www.imgtec.com/news/press-r...nounces-ray-tracing-technology-for-licensing/

Right or wrong its what i'm expecting. If the two sides have different RT implementation (which I believe has been stated before) than I can't imagine they are both just using AMD's RDNA2 implementation. It would also tie into that Sony engineers comments on the RDNA 2's RT abilities.

In this setup, you maintain the hardware backcompat that you are comfortable with to ensure full BC (disable full WGPs and downclock) while you also get to have you custom RT solution that you have been working on because you weren't sure if AMD would ever get there. IMO Sony wanted to lean on RT and likely started down their own path to get there. There is also no need to add an extra WGP on chip if you have your own RT solution. That seems to be a big waste.

Also, focusing on hardware backcompat on a new architecture would require quite a bit of testing which makes sense as to why you would lock in the chip early and step often.

I just can't reconcile how both sides would have different RT results if they are effectively using the exact same chip and architecture. MS will be leaning on DirectX RT and I don't see why Sony would go that way. Also, if you aren't relying on AMD's RT you don't need the extra TF in the APU and you wouldn't see any AMD RT testing on the chips.

The issue with this is the assumption that RT will be handled by the CUs on the GPU of the series X. If they are implementing hardware acceleration for RT then it would have cores specifically handling this that are not part of the GPU compute performance. Correct me if I'm wrong
 

rntongo

Banned
BTW, Jim Ryan's main point of 'the bigger differences [vs PS4] have yet to be revealed' comment is about PS5 backwards compatibility will run "almost all" previous PlayStation games to date. (PS1, PS2, PS4 and PS3 included). This is gonna be the one big step forward for them in start of the next generation and a true meltdown.
And that's not all
And here I thought it was ML cores on the die
 

Sosokrates

Report me if I continue to console war
The issue with this is the assumption that RT will be handled by the CUs on the GPU of the series X. If they are implementing hardware acceleration for RT then it would have cores specifically handling this that are not part of the GPU compute performance. Correct me if I'm wrong

There was a patent for AMD Ray tracing, and the way it works is that the RT hardware is built into each compute unit.

66455_01_amds-new-patent-explains-hybrid-ray-tracing-approach.jpg


 
Last edited:

Null_Key

Neo Member
If Sony were more powerful you would think that they would of reacted some way to the 12tf news from Phil. Why let Xbox bask in its 12tf glory? It would of been a megaton if Sony tweeted "13.2TFLOPS" after the Spencer article. It is odd and not like Sony, Sony like to react quite dynamnicly.
On the contrary while it may seem like a good business practice, trolling a superior specs out there isn't very professional to begin with. To be honest I don't believe Sony would have said anything whether it has superior specs or not. Sony even with the PS4 gave vague information, until teams such as digital foundry decided to have a deep dive into the unit. Silence doesn't equate inferiority. Fanboys tries to make it a blood-shedding rivalry but Sony and Microsoft really only have to answer to there stakeholders. They may have a friendly banters between the two companies from time to time, but it's doubtful one will have an impact on another on timeline set for there reveal, on the other hand talent scouting is a different story, talented developers studios are hard to come by and companies acquisition network can be quite cutthroat, another aspect of this is securing manufacturing service, Companies like Foxconn only have so much capability to produce parts, many IT Companies fight to secure a contract for both priority and production count.
 

rntongo

Banned
There was a patent for AMD Ray tracing, and the way it works is that the RT hardware is built into each compute unit.

66455_01_amds-new-patent-explains-hybrid-ray-tracing-approach.jpg

Actually this implementation is better than having separate cores on the die. This saves space on the die while also taking load off the GPU so the TFLOPs do not account for the RT solution. The 12 tflops do not account for the RT. Correct me if I'm wrong
 
Last edited:

Sosokrates

Report me if I continue to console war
On the contrary while it may seem like a good business practice, trolling a superior specs out there isn't very professional to begin with. To be honest I don't believe Sony would have said anything whether it has superior specs or not. Sony even with the PS4 gave vague information, until teams such as digital foundry decided to have a deep dive into the unit. Silence doesn't equate inferiority. Fanboys tries to make it a blood-shedding rivalry but Sony and Microsoft really only have to answer to there stakeholders. They may have a friendly banters between the two companies from time to time, but it's doubtful one will have an impact on another on timeline set for there reveal, on the other hand talent scouting is a different story, talented developers studios are hard to come by and companies acquisition network can be quite cutthroat, another aspect of this is securing manufacturing service, Companies like Foxconn only have so much capability to produce parts, many IT Companies fight to secure a contract for both priority and production count.

Well we have seen this back forth and game of one upmanship between Sony + Xbox. So it's not a matter of opinion we are seeing both companies play this game regarding the release of next gen console info.
 

longdi

Banned
Sony Shu filmed the second hand games video on site and uploaded to YT hours after Xb1 presser.

No 13tflops tweet, pure silence = bad news.
Im trying to lower expectations for ultimate ps5 disappointment
 

FranXico

Member
No i remember they decided to film that video as a response to MS E3
The video was made at E3, mocking MS, but everybody knew about the DRM long before the MS press conference.
There was also a lot of FUD going around about the PS4 having the same DRM. That's what the Sony press conference, together with that silly and actually unnecessary video, responded to. Not just the MS press conference.
 
Last edited:

ethomaz

Banned
No i remember they decided to film that video as a response to MS E3
Nope.
The video was recorded two days before the E3 presentation when they were doing the rehearsal of presentation.

It was in response of DRM in MS Xbox One reveal in early May... a month before E3.

The video only exists because a lot of fake rumors about PS4 having the same DRM features.
 
Last edited:

FranXico

Member
They were quite quick taking advantage of the Xbox one mishaps at the start of this gen.
No way was jack trettons used games/always online speech was not changed based on what ms said.
That speech happened at E3, long after the reveal and that the Xbox One DRM was known. You call that quick?
 

HolyTruth

Banned
Guys you all have to calm down. Sheesh!

Our text was pretty flaky because he was getting the information from a very high profile worker at Sony.

The text seems to be all over the place.

I never got dates nor prices. As I said before, "expensive" to me means near Nvidia 2080 costs. The guessing is all on me so take it with a grain of salt.

PS5 as of now is 9TF. I specifically asked that and got a yes.

PS5 falls in between performance of the Lockheart and the XSX. That is confirmed.

The iffy part is the PS5 Pro.

"they have one model with lower specs than PS5 and one model with higher specs. PS5 is right in the middle" -- talking about the Xbox SKUs.

"tons of rumors that the lower spec xbox is coming out this year".

"XSX is equivalent to the RTX 2080 super"

"unless they plan on selling it for $800 I doubt it will release anytime soon." -- XSX coming out later??

There is other comments like if XSX sells for $500 then that would disrupt Nvidia sells, etc.."

Anyway, I tried to piece together was is happening. It appears like the PS5 Pro is coming later. That would mean the base PS5 is 9TF and perhaps the 2 SKUs for Xbox are releasing during xmas 2020.

So 2 models. Possible 2 coming out from Microsoft but 1 coming out for Sony.

I'm just as confused as you guys but I won't press for straight answers.
Wtf did I just read?!
 

hemo memo

You can't die before your death
They were quite quick taking advantage of the Xbox one mishaps at the start of this gen.
No way was jack trettons used games/always online speech was not changed based on what ms said.

You play your competitor weakness but Microsoft is being quiet. If I’m in charge of Xbox twitter social media team I would let them post this every time someone mention the PS5

tenor.gif
 
Last edited:

Sosokrates

Report me if I continue to console war
Actually this implementation is better than having separate cores on the die. This saves space on the die while also taking load off the GPU so the TFLOPs do not account for the RT solution. The 12 tflops do not account for the RT. Correct me if I'm wrong

From my understanding the compute unit works with the RT hardware, so it's not separate. However I'm not an engineer, I just know what I read on the article.
 

PocoJoe

Banned
Funny how so many at here think that huge companies are like kids at playground

"my dad can lift 100kg!"

"m-m-my dad can lift 200kg!!"

"no..no mine can lift 2000kg!!!"

it would be silly to assume that company would instantly spam their spec sheet out after one releases their, it's not a valid reason to assume that ps5 is weak when Sony doesnt show their cards.

They are clear winner of this gen and they have no hurry, also by waiting they can control the hype and even add (software) features if they are ready sooner than they thought
 

Koopatrol

Member
Funny how so many at here think that huge companies are like kids at playground

"my dad can lift 100kg!"

"m-m-my dad can lift 200kg!!"

"no..no mine can lift 2000kg!!!"

it would be silly to assume that company would instantly spam their spec sheet out after one releases their, it's not a valid reason to assume that ps5 is weak when Sony doesnt show their cards.

They are clear winner of this gen and they have no hurry, also by waiting they can control the hype and even add (software) features if they are ready sooner than they thought

It's like people keep forgetting that the PS4 still has top software coming out this year, and they have to plan around that accordingly. Meanwhile Xbox is more than ready to move onto next gen.

Both companies are playing to their strengths at the moment: I'm definitely excited for the upcoming PS4 software this year and PS5, and the Xbox Series X looks enticing as hell.
 
Funny how so many at here think that huge companies are like kids at playground

"my dad can lift 100kg!"

"m-m-my dad can lift 200kg!!"

"no..no mine can lift 2000kg!!!"

it would be silly to assume that company would instantly spam their spec sheet out after one releases their, it's not a valid reason to assume that ps5 is weak when Sony doesnt show their cards.

They are clear winner of this gen and they have no hurry, also by waiting they can control the hype and even add (software) features if they are ready sooner than they thought

Actually companies do act like that. nintendo hides the specs of there consoles because of how weak it is, Microsoft started hiding console sales because it's being demolished by ps4. Companies do not like bad PR. I think Microsoft pretty much knows ps5 will be less powerful so they flat showed all the cards, while imo sony know's its much weaker. lets also not forget when sega saturn announced 399$ and sony right after announced 299$ on the same stage.
 

DJ12

Member
I want to know what 5a, 5c and 5d are.
devkits are usually much powerful than retail units.
For ms maybe, they over power at the beginning with the pc based devkits they usually send out and then as the console design gets closer they put the console hardware in which is usually on par with retail, maybe a bit more powerful.

Sony tend to low ball from the start and build to retail power with more memory
If Sony were more powerful you would think that they would of reacted some way to the 12tf news from Phil. Why let Xbox bask in its 12tf glory? It would of been a megaton if Sony tweeted "13.2TFLOPS" after the Spencer article. It is odd and not like Sony, Sony like to react quite dynamnicly.
Maybe they don't care at the moment due to the ongoing crisis in the world. You can take the silence as confirmation if you like but the opposite is likely true given ms are in a rush to release info and still cannot say it's the most powerful console ever made.

However sony have said this in a job posting, which was altered a day or so later.

Ms will know by now if they are stronger or not. If we are getting info they will be getting a lot more for sure.
 

Zoro7

Banned
Actually companies do act like that. nintendo hides the specs of there consoles because of how weak it is, Microsoft started hiding console sales because it's being demolished by ps4. Companies do not like bad PR. I think Microsoft pretty much knows ps5 will be less powerful so they flat showed all the cards, while imo sony know's its much weaker. lets also not forget when sega saturn announced 399$ and sony right after announced 299$ on the same stage.
Microsoft showed all the cards because they took a big battering the last 7 years. This is their way of getting a few minutes of fame before Sony comes in.
And yes it is possible the PS5 might be weaker but I seriously dont think this will have an impact unless the difference is substantial. Which I can guarantee it wont be.
 

MARTYWOLF

Member
Microsoft showed all the cards because they took a big battering the last 7 years. This is their way of getting a few minutes of fame before Sony comes in.
And yes it is possible the PS5 might be weaker but I seriously dont think this will have an impact unless the difference is substantial. Which I can guarantee it wont be.


MS should focus on beating xbox one sales performance first, while making good games if they dont put all the devs they have bought to use some people are gonna be mad aha
 

hemo memo

You can't die before your death
Funny how so many at here think that huge companies are like kids at playground

"my dad can lift 100kg!"

"m-m-my dad can lift 200kg!!"

"no..no mine can lift 2000kg!!!"

it would be silly to assume that company would instantly spam their spec sheet out after one releases their, it's not a valid reason to assume that ps5 is weak when Sony doesnt show their cards.

They are clear winner of this gen and they have no hurry, also by waiting they can control the hype and even add (software) features if they are ready sooner than they thought

Nah it’s a fair assumption because we have seen it time and time again in this industry. If the company is too quiet then high chance they’re screwing up something.
 
Microsoft showed all the cards because they took a big battering the last 7 years. This is their way of getting a few minutes of fame before Sony comes in.
And yes it is possible the PS5 might be weaker but I seriously dont think this will have an impact unless the difference is substantial. Which I can guarantee it wont be.

The github leaks are 90% confirmed at this point. all the insiders have been wrong so far. ps5 will most likely be 9.2 teraflops.
 

hemo memo

You can't die before your death
Japan shut down their ENTIRE school system due to CODIV-19 and not just for a few days.




“It seems really extreme and really sudden,” said Chelsea Szendi Schieder, an associate professor of economics at Aoyama Gakuin University in Tokyo. “And the implications for people and their daily lives is going to be so big that I’m not sure it’s worth it in terms of public health.”

Kentaro Iwata, an infectious-disease specialist at Kobe University who had criticized the government’s response to the coronavirus outbreak on the Diamond Princess, said school closings were not medically warranted.

“I don’t understand this,” Dr. Iwata said. “Primarily, children are not easily infected with coronavirus, and even if they are infected, they don’t easily fall seriously ill.”

Analysts said political calculations might have weighed more heavily than science, particularly with the Olympics scheduled to begin in July.

“The Olympics have cast a shadow over the government’s response this whole time,” said Tobias Harris, an expert on Japanese politics at Teneo Intelligence in Washington.

“Early on, the response was a little timid and reactive for fear of alienating international visitors,” he said, “and now they’re belatedly realizing that unless they can somehow stop this or contain it that the chances of cancellation seem to be growing by the day.”

Japan Shocks Parents by Moving to Close All Schools Over Coronavirus
 
Nah it’s a fair assumption because we have seen it time and time again in this industry. If the company is too quiet then high chance they’re screwing up something.
In Sony's situation, their DS5 is quite advanced. Their updating patents for it a lot the last couple weeks. They wont unveil PS5 without speaking about DS5 and showing it (even if they dont show console box), just yesterday there were patents for DS5 wireless charging with mat or adapter (no cables), this silence is planned.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom