Joe Molotov
Member
Ah okay, I hadn't seen there was a new one.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Magic: the Gathering |OT8| Eldritch Moon - It's only a paper (and digital) moon
- Thread starter SigmasonicX
- Start date
- Status
Huh, why is Sorin ashen skinned when the other Innistrad vampires have normal human skin colors again?I just can't get over the expression on this lady listening to Sorin run his mouth in this new illustration. I feel like this is gonna get a lot of use.
I mean just look how much she isn't into Sorin's shit.
TheBlackMarvel
Member
Planeswalker Spark?
The problem there is that that is still a trigger. So with that wording, when it leaves the battlefield, this happens:
1) Queller leaves the battlefield
2) Exiled spell appears on the stack, without targets or any choices made.
3) Trigger goes on the stack.
4) Trigger resolves, owner casts the spell (which puts the spell back on the stack), makes choices
5) Spell resolves.
Step 2 is a weird scenario that isn't really covered in the rules. And it gets super weird if say, the cast trigger gets Stifled. So just skipping that and having the cast trigger take the spell from Exile to the Stack is cleaner.
This should be entertaining to resolve.
The box! The box!
You can hold onto your Negate and Island or YOU CAN GO FOR WHAT'S IN THE BOX!
It's always 2 islands
NOTHING! ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! STUPID! YOU'RE SO STUPID!
Simply Sarah
Member
I wonder if Spell Qweller + Displacer + on cast trigger will be a thing? I'm leaning towards no since it's not clear there's enough to work with to payoff such a combo.
Edit: To be more clear, due to the CMC limit on the effect it means that most flashy on cast effects are off limits and even if they weren't I doubt there'd be much real value to it beyond being a bit cute.
Edit: To be more clear, due to the CMC limit on the effect it means that most flashy on cast effects are off limits and even if they weren't I doubt there'd be much real value to it beyond being a bit cute.
It's still not entirely clear to me why splitting the trigger in two alleviates issues with how to handle the exiled spell that one trigger runs into but I admit that I'm running on low sleep right now. Maybe I'll ask Tabak later.
As an aside, Nahiri trying to force Emrakul onto Innistrad because Sorin wasn't vigilant enough to make sure things on Zendikar didn't go to shit just strikes me as vindictive and petty. An obvious case of "two wrongs don't make a right".
As an aside, Nahiri trying to force Emrakul onto Innistrad because Sorin wasn't vigilant enough to make sure things on Zendikar didn't go to shit just strikes me as vindictive and petty. An obvious case of "two wrongs don't make a right".
TheBlackMarvel
Member
It just struck me, with Nahiri being the new face of villainy and Sorin trapped in a container he can only speak out of, they're now the Rita and Zordon of the GateRangers.
Lots of people here argue she's justified. I'm with you. She's a turd.
charlequin
Banned
It's really just about how a spell can get onto the stack. Under the rules, it's only by being cast or otherwise put there by an effect that defines any choices and targets necessary. If this card put the spell back on the stack itself, it'd need to define all that stuff and spend a bunch of wording explaining how choices and targets work etc. By just leaving it in exile and letting the person cast it, all that work is just done by the normal spell rules.
Oh, I mean, it's clearly morally abhorrent and awful and she's clearly the block's primary villain. My point is really just that she turns to morally abhorrent behavior after immeasurable grief and 1000 years cooling her heels in the Helvault while Sorin just does it casually before breakfast.
darkside31337
Tomodachi wa Mahou
Spell Queller is -insane-. Most likely going to be the best card in the set by a ridiculous margin.
Keru_Shiri
Member
No joke. It's even grosser that this can slot into Bant Company so easily.
darkside31337
Tomodachi wa Mahou
I really can't believe they gave coco another piece to toolbox with.
Giant Panda
Member
It is very reminiscent of Thought-knot seer, which is an amazing card, so I wouldn't be surprised.
SigmasonicX
Member
Magic Story - Campaign of Vengeance
* Sorin and a Voldaren family army arrive at Markov Manor, where Nahiri is waiting with a bunch of cultists, who worship her as the Harbinger.
* A fight breaks out. Nahiri fights combining sword attacks with earthbending. After seeing Sorin, she creates walls to separate them from the rest of the battle.
* Sorin tries to use death magic on her, but it just gets redirected back toward him. Nahiri messed with the leylines that his magic would have flowed through, using her monoliths.
* Sorin and Nahiri talk. Nahiri is angry that he and Ugin didn't do anything about the Eldrazi. She's done being a warden and with Zendikar being a prison; Sorin made it easy to decide where else to put them.
* Olivia interrupts and has vampires descend on Nahiri. Nahiri forms swords which... I guess cause the vampires to stop, it doesn't actually say what happens to them.
* Nahiri uses her magic to rotate the entire manor like a music box, causing an otherworldly sound, while she forms ley stones around her. This draws Eldrazi there, and they ignore her due to the ley stones.
* Nahiri leaves and Sorin follows. They fight. Anime style, Sorin moves so fast that Nahiri loses track of him. To defend herself, she encases herself in stone, and Sorin taunts her for being so used to the Helvault. Sorin's sword is able to pierce through the stone.
* Sorin bites into her neck and starts draining her blood. Nahiri makes jaws of stone close around him and breaks away. The stone will prevent him from planeswalking away.
* Nahiri leaves, planeswalking away. Olivia taunts Sorin in his prison and leaves him there, despite Sorin telling her she'll need him to stop Emrakul. I guess the artbook was completely wrong about how Olivia dies, and Sorin's attitude about Emrakul.
* Sorin and a Voldaren family army arrive at Markov Manor, where Nahiri is waiting with a bunch of cultists, who worship her as the Harbinger.
* A fight breaks out. Nahiri fights combining sword attacks with earthbending. After seeing Sorin, she creates walls to separate them from the rest of the battle.
* Sorin tries to use death magic on her, but it just gets redirected back toward him. Nahiri messed with the leylines that his magic would have flowed through, using her monoliths.
* Sorin and Nahiri talk. Nahiri is angry that he and Ugin didn't do anything about the Eldrazi. She's done being a warden and with Zendikar being a prison; Sorin made it easy to decide where else to put them.
* Olivia interrupts and has vampires descend on Nahiri. Nahiri forms swords which... I guess cause the vampires to stop, it doesn't actually say what happens to them.
* Nahiri uses her magic to rotate the entire manor like a music box, causing an otherworldly sound, while she forms ley stones around her. This draws Eldrazi there, and they ignore her due to the ley stones.
* Nahiri leaves and Sorin follows. They fight. Anime style, Sorin moves so fast that Nahiri loses track of him. To defend herself, she encases herself in stone, and Sorin taunts her for being so used to the Helvault. Sorin's sword is able to pierce through the stone.
* Sorin bites into her neck and starts draining her blood. Nahiri makes jaws of stone close around him and breaks away. The stone will prevent him from planeswalking away.
* Nahiri leaves, planeswalking away. Olivia taunts Sorin in his prison and leaves him there, despite Sorin telling her she'll need him to stop Emrakul. I guess the artbook was completely wrong about how Olivia dies, and Sorin's attitude about Emrakul.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
You guys make it sound like its a binary choice between good and evil. Nahiri being insane isn't unreasonable to begin with. Sorin locked her in a dark room for 1000 years without a second thought about whether that was right.
Also, the title of this Uncharted Realms should have been "Senpai Noticed"
Also, the title of this Uncharted Realms should have been "Senpai Noticed"
TheBlackMarvel
Member
I don't know about that, it looked like he was grasping to save himself. He still considers Innistrad doomed in the long run.
I love Spell Queller a lot. Any eternal game in which an Abrupt Decay gets spell-quelled is instantly going to be an exciting game.
But yeah, other than that guy and the Venser counterspell (which has been a star in my custom card cube for years, glad it finally got printed), the set's pretty unexciting so far.
But yeah, other than that guy and the Venser counterspell (which has been a star in my custom card cube for years, glad it finally got printed), the set's pretty unexciting so far.
Reprint Flame Slash in every standard, please. Keeps people honest!
SigmasonicX
Member
Chaos Reveler is a really neat card. I'm glad red is getting more "discard your hand, draw a set number of cards" effects.
And you can even discard it to Nahiri's Wrath. This is even a "wrath effect" where it's worthwhile to cast madness creatures you discard, since you don't have to damage them. The fact that you deal the total damage to each creature (or planeswalker) is nice. In a pinch, you could discard your hard to take out all of your opponent's creatures, even the big ones.
Campaign of Vengeance is the last of the enemy color uncommon cycle. Now it makes sense that they held it back, since it's story related. It seems alright, but it already didn't see play on a 3B 3/3 creature with another ability.
Spell Queller is neat, but definitely not what this Standard needs.
Fortune's Favor is neat, and I see someone already made the UHF joke.
Dark Salvation was a bit confusing in its usefulness, until the source article pointed this out:
The weakening effect is based on the number of zombies. And if nothing else, 2B for a 2/2 zombie that can kill a weak creature seems decent.
And you can even discard it to Nahiri's Wrath. This is even a "wrath effect" where it's worthwhile to cast madness creatures you discard, since you don't have to damage them. The fact that you deal the total damage to each creature (or planeswalker) is nice. In a pinch, you could discard your hard to take out all of your opponent's creatures, even the big ones.
Campaign of Vengeance is the last of the enemy color uncommon cycle. Now it makes sense that they held it back, since it's story related. It seems alright, but it already didn't see play on a 3B 3/3 creature with another ability.
Spell Queller is neat, but definitely not what this Standard needs.
Fortune's Favor is neat, and I see someone already made the UHF joke.
Dark Salvation was a bit confusing in its usefulness, until the source article pointed this out:
The weakening effect is based on the number of zombies. And if nothing else, 2B for a 2/2 zombie that can kill a weak creature seems decent.
It might have been better if they had the ability to write Magic Story in a longer form but as it has been written Nahiri's logic/reasoning never felt particularly sensible. In fact, I think her justification for pulling Emrakul to Innistrad is far more understandable than her initial, stupid as fuck reaction to Sorin not showing up on Zendikar to help seal the Eldrazi back in their hedron prison. Sorin's reaction wasn't particularly great either but at least it was on point for the character and understandable from the point of view that he's so old and disconnected from the living world that at best he's going to come off as aloof. The "Do what I say" and "I must defeat Sorin to show him that I'm no longer a 'child'" rationale that Nahiri gives for attacking Sorin initially is asinine, imo. The second story about that encounter, from her perspective rather than Sorin's, was better than the initial one but it still felt forced.
Her reaction after being locked away for so long is a lot more understandable than the initial fight between the two. It could have been written in such a way as to make it escalate to that point in a more reasonable fashion rather than:
Nahiri: Thank goodness, I thought you were dead Sorin!
Sorin: I'm fine.
Nahiri: Why didn't you answer the call to seal the Eldrazi? You promised!
Sorin: Hmm... the call didn't reach me. *gives a reasonable explanation*
Nahiri: You're coming with me to Zendikar NOW to make sure the Eldrazi are all taken care of!
Sorin: Child, don't tell me what to do.
Nahiri: I must now attack you to prove that I'm no longer your lesser! Then you'll do what I say! RAAAWR!
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Aw, Cube doesn't start for a week? I thought it was the holiday cube? WTF. Holiday's over, pal.
charlequin
Banned
It's weird to me that Monday was a sack of butt and then today we get like four different powerful and/or interesting to build around cards.
I'm really sad that Spell Queller is going to be an obnoxious as fuck CoCo piece because it's really nifty in a vacuum. I know they don't ban cards in Standard really but it's hard to say it wouldn't be better for the format if they didn't just ditch that card one set early.
I'm really sad that Spell Queller is going to be an obnoxious as fuck CoCo piece because it's really nifty in a vacuum. I know they don't ban cards in Standard really but it's hard to say it wouldn't be better for the format if they didn't just ditch that card one set early.
People shouldn't fall for this stuff. It's creating its own problem. If you just refrain from buying cards you don't actually need, prices won't actually up by much. That's the problem with Magic. People buy cards to sell them for a margin, but those get picked up by people who want to do the same. Eventually the prices go up just because everyone is holding out on them but those copies never get used for the actual game. Worst thing in Magic that there's no such thing as dividend or voting rights. There's not much you can do other than driving the price up if you want a profit.
The Technomancer
card-carrying scientician
Ohhhhhh
Dark Salvation is confusingly worded.
I thought that you had to give the opponent the zombies to kill their stuff
The "target player" wording is super weird otherwise, except for the 1% of limited games where its somehow...anti...zombie...tech?
Dark Salvation is confusingly worded.
I thought that you had to give the opponent the zombies to kill their stuff
The "target player" wording is super weird otherwise, except for the 1% of limited games where its somehow...anti...zombie...tech?
Players: "We need more Blue permission!"
Wizards of the Coast: *Maniacal laughter*
"God's Beard!"
Member
I don't get it
This card is great. It's basically outnumber + white sun's zenith on the same card. If you play a deck that can reliably cast this as Dead Weight then you're in business. The late game upside of playing this for 7+ mana is nuts.
6 mana shock + forked bolt, and that's the upside.
SigmasonicX
Member
Aww man, why does Dark Salvation have to target a player? I wanted to explode Mirrorwing Dragon or Zada into a pile of Zombies
Now I realize that's probably precisely why it targets a player in addition to the creature.
"God's Beard!"
Member
So much has to go right for it to even be a 1 for 1, and then it's probably below rate. Maybe if Boros Reckoner or something was in standard and there was some insane combo. I guess you could use it as a discard outlet for an Ever After deck or something.
Mark me for unimpressed.
Mark me for unimpressed.
SigmasonicX
Member
[QUOTE="God's Beard!";209303038]So much has to go right for it to even be a 1 for 1, and then it's probably below rate. Maybe if Boros Reckoner or something was in standard and there was some insane combo. I guess you could use it as a discard outlet for an Ever After deck or something.
Mark me for unimpressed.[/QUOTE]
Talking about Nahiri's Wrath, I presume?
Mark me for unimpressed.[/QUOTE]
Talking about Nahiri's Wrath, I presume?
charlequin
Banned
I mean, yes, that's correct, but good luck getting people not to buy high like saps in any open market.
Targeting a player means you still get zombies if the opponent sacs the creature target in response.
A Serious Man
Member
The fact that Nahiri's Wrath literally does nothing by itself ain't great. It's an awful draw late in the game, unless you've been hoarding stuff to dump with it which doesn't sound like a good scenario either.
Keru_Shiri
Member
I'm sure I'm missing something but Nahiris Wrath just doesn't seem that good. I guess it's better for midrange decks, or with a bunch of madness cards. Just seems kinda win-more if you're in a position where you can comfortably pitch a bunch of fuel to it.
Yeah. I'm sure there's a way to make it work.
Goggles?
Plus the art is so FUCKIN BADASS
charlequin
Banned
BTW, I don't think we talked about this, but Corbin Hosler did an interview with the buyout guy:
http://blog.mtgprice.com/2016/07/05/an-interview-with-the-man-behind-the-buyouts/
Good interview and good writeup, I think the guy does a very good job of presenting his case, and he very specifically notes that he's buying stuff out that he can sell slowly over years rather than pump and dump. (That doesn't make it less disruptive overall, though.)
http://blog.mtgprice.com/2016/07/05/an-interview-with-the-man-behind-the-buyouts/
Good interview and good writeup, I think the guy does a very good job of presenting his case, and he very specifically notes that he's buying stuff out that he can sell slowly over years rather than pump and dump. (That doesn't make it less disruptive overall, though.)
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
The problem is that he's converting liquid capital into cardboard that doesn't have enough demand to sell out at its current price, much less the phony valuation he pegged it at. 41 Moats isn't all of the Moats in the world.
There's not enough actual demand in the marketplace to buy all those cards and dump them immediately. If that were the case they would have spiked on their own with organic demand. I did find this section
a little gross, and frankly, a little irresponsible on Corbin's part considering the logical MTGPrice audience's response to the article would be this and this That section just felt like he was throwing cards out there that he already owned in the hopes of priming demand with the audience the article would give him (much like his videos).
Familienoberhauptvogel
Banned
really, it looks lazy imo. She's just shooting swords in random directions.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked