• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dee_Dee

Member
There's also Summer Game Fest going on all summer, which has a Cyberpunk thing and EA Play in June.
Ahhh okay I knew I was forgetting some things. Thanks. That makes sense then. Don’t wanna crowd June up with everything.

Wish we had a thread dedicated to all the events happening
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Was wondering why there are lot of $$$ discussions on a gaming forum !

Sony was a great company, still does a lot of things good. But please, it is not in the same league as MS. Your hatred for Xbox brand, doesnt qualify you to bash MS. You are trying to compare a 75 billion dollar to a 1400 billion dollar business.

Here is the list of companies by their worth : https://www.dogsofthedow.com/largest-companies-by-market-cap.htm

Japan's economy has plateaued. Its all destiny BOSS, If Sony Sharp etc etc had not failed, Korea wouldnt be a developed nation today.

$1.4 trillion theoretical number again? You know what? I drop it here.
 
  • LOL
Reactions: TLZ

Gamernyc78

Banned
Speak for yourself. Not everyone is interested in a rental service full of indie to AA titles with a sprinkle of MS exclusives. I mean, it's fine for a dollar a month but when their promo ends, and it's inevitable it will end one day, a lot of those 10 million 1-dollar customers will cancel their subs. What will happen to the Xbox division then?


They should've started acquiring those studios 3-4 years ago. What the hell were they thinking? "Let's make new hardware and we'll think about software later?" If they hadn't said that themselves, I'd have thought that launching a console without exclusives is a story from someone's ass because no platform holder would do that. But here we are...


He's just parroting what he was told to think.
1239128604271218863.gif

I had gamepass for a month, played Gears 5 mp and the game for like three days then unsubscribed. None of those old games kept me or the AA recore, Sea of Thieves, etc
 
Since sony is going early june the earliest we can expect announcement from the is next Tuesday onwards .I would say 2 Tuesdays from now so around 26 sony will tease and announce the date
 

Neo Blaster

Member
There's also Summer Game Fest going on all summer, which has a Cyberpunk thing and EA Play in June.
Ubisoft is the only big publisher not listed among the ones in SGF site, probably won't be included since they've already announced their own event.
 
Last edited:
$1.4 trillion theoretical number again? You know what? I drop it here.
Who said it is a theoretical number ? Its a collated statistic.

Let me give you a simple example,
In USA, a home that yields 1000$ monthly rental, costs ~ 400,000$ (median). Take the ratio (33.33) and apply it to a business,
A business making 45bn$ (projected this year profits of Microsoft), it would be valued at 33.33*45bn = 1499 bn $.
How does it sound ? Now,in the biggest US cities, where the education/oppurtunities are the best, the home prices are even higher.
 

Mod of War

Ω
Staff Member
Who said it is a theoretical number ? Its a collated statistic.

Let me give you a simple example,
In USA, a home that yields 1000$ monthly rental, costs ~ 400,000$ (median). Take the ratio (33.33) and apply it to a business,
A business making 45bn$ (projected this year profits of Microsoft), it would be valued at 33.33*45bn = 1499 bn $.
How does it sound ? Now,in the biggest US cities, where the education/oppurtunities are the best, the home prices are even higher.

Move on from the net worth wars meta in here, and bring it to a sales-age thread. This goes for everyone.
 
You're mixing up the estimated price of buying Microsoft as a whole because of how many shareholders are there, it doesn't mean it has that money, at all. Who would buy it for 1 trillion anyway? You see? Theoretical, the actual is $110B gross annual revenue with $70B debt.

Anyway, this point has been already discussed around, so I'm out of it.
Mod of War Mod of War My last msg on this topic.
Bo_Hazem Bo_Hazem You are saying cash, then revenue. Stick to one point. Sony is also a traded public entity. The rules that apply to Ms, apply to Sony as well. You are trolling without facts, at this point. I am teaching all this to you, to make you rich brother :messenger_sunglasses: .
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Why? He lied in here for months. If he had stuck around and taken his lumps I would've been fine with it, but he peaced out instead. The dude played us all for fools, at least those of us who actually believed his nonsense. Good riddance.

I still believe that him and his sources got confused with the total TF. The CPU/GPU and the equivalent of 11x zen2 cores in the i/o, the GPU-based tempest engine, an alien API that used incompatible app to calculate TF's = gross, inaccurate collective TF.

I personally give him the benefit of the doubt.
 
Last edited:
It’s interesting that so many events are being planned for July instead of June.

For June we have a rumored Sony showing and what else...that Guerrila Collective

May not be the same but we had to make decisions like this at my company. We had hard dates for events/unveil, and because of COVID-19, we took it as an opportunity to delay a few weeks and strategize around unique virtual engagements.

I’m sure Ubi did the same once E3 wasn’t a thing. It’s easier to ride the coattails of a major event like that than plan your own, especially with how much everything has changed/been impacted lately.
 

ethomaz

Banned
They didn't. There was a lot of speculation and rumours that Phison was supplying the controller, based on a previous employee stating at his Linkedin, that he worked on a controller which was installed in "Xbox Scarlet":



There is no official confirmation, whatsoever. Phison does not want to breach their NDA, if they are indeed supplying.

That is not what happened.
There is a Digitimes report from Supply Chain but you need to pay to read.


You can read here too: https://www.ithome.com/0/468/512.htm
 
Last edited:

Games Dean

Member
I still believe that him and his sources got confused with the total TF. The CPU/GPU and the equivalent of 11x zen2 cores in the i/o, the GPU-based tempest engine, an alien API for that used app to calculate TF's = gross, inaccurate collective TF.

I personally give him the benefit of the doubt.

I can see where you're coming from. I'd be more inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt if he hadn't done this before (PS4 pro).

Shoutout Heisenberg for sticking around though. Good contributor to the thread and was much closer to official specs than other "insiders".
 

TBiddy

Member

ethomaz

Banned
It was, along with the above. When are you posting that “official confirmation” you were talking about?

We both know that official confirmation doesn’t exist.
And you create a false rumor about linkdn lol

You can read here too: https://www.ithome.com/0/468/512.htm

BTW you probably can't open the Digitimes reports so I will transcript.

"In addition, memory device controller IC suppliers including Phison Electronics and Silicon Motion Technology are also poised to embrace strong demand for SSDs for gaming consoles in 2020, the sources noted. Phison has reportedly broken into the supply chain of Microsoft's Xbox, while Silicon Motion has seen orders for home consoles with built-in SSDs surge. "

 
Last edited:

TBiddy

Member
"In addition, memory device controller IC suppliers including Phison Electronics and Silicon Motion Technology are also poised to embrace strong demand for SSDs for gaming consoles in 2020, the sources noted. Phison has reportedly broken into the supply chain of Microsoft's Xbox, while Silicon Motion has seen orders for home consoles with built-in SSDs surge. "

That’s not an official confirmation from Phison. When are you posting it?

The LinkedIn story was very real. You can see the image and the tweet for crying out loud.
 

Bryank75

Banned
If you can't effectively saturate a 2.5gb SSD, why would you even try to go to a 7.5 (which is nonsense anyway)....
The trick to PS5 is the 5.5gb SSD in combination with the 12 channel controller, which saturates almost the entire 5.5 gb pretty much instantly.
 

rntongo

Banned
If you can't effectively saturate a 2.5gb SSD, why would you even try to go to a 7.5 (which is nonsense anyway)....
The trick to PS5 is the 5.5gb SSD in combination with the 12 channel controller, which saturates almost the entire 5.5 gb pretty much instantly.

The E19 controller has a max speed of 3.7GB/s from what I’ve read and can support up to 2TB. Also, most likely MSFT customized it for their needs. On the other hand, someone on reddit made a good case for why the PS5 SSD controller is a custom variant of the more advanced e16 controller.
 

Bryank75

Banned
I'll bite. What are you basing your claim on, that the XSX is unable to "effectively saturate a 2.5 GB SSD"?
Precisely... it's in one of the Inocenceii videos, he explains why he is impressed with the PS5 SSD and the differences between it and Xbox's SSD with a nice animated illustration.
 
Definitely not cheaper or easier. If you want to do this, it's going to cost you money. You need a specific team to "dumb down" your game towards the low-end system. But take for example 343i on Halo. That team is huge, the costs of that game will be huge, that's GTA level of game cost development. So indeed not every studio is able to do this, but this is about Microsoft's first party studios. They have those capabilities.


I agree that it's not all about graphics. The capabilities of the SSD lay mostly in creating more detailed and immersive worlds. So we don't get the 50 of the same books in every library (just an example), but actual 1000 of different possible books because now the input towards our GPU is much faster thanks to the SSD. So we can show more stuff. From close distance to long distance. I'm merely saying that in your opinion you believe developers aren't able to dumb that down for other lower end systems. In my opinion they can, which is based on Microsoft already doing something similar with Rise of the tomb raider. Why wouldn't they be able to do this?
I think both side a lost a reason of why the generation changes is not only is before was possible to do A thing is because in order to accomplish A they need to expend to many
time and money to be worth so A never was released not because was not possible if not they will not see worth to do all the require works.

So now with a good CPU and SSD they can do things than before was not possible but more important reasonable do it, Cerny don't want the games just see another increment
in price production that is why he cares so much what the dev think, that is why Xbox follow a similar approach.

For example Medium for XSX a true new gen exclusive which says:


"I can't tell you right now about our most important feature, because we will have to save it for later. But the gameplay mechanic built around those two worlds couldn't be fully realized
on current-gen hardware. This is something that I think will distinguish our game from any other. It's also even patented. So yeah, the game simply cannot work the same way on current-gen
platforms. And that's why we are developing the game for Xbox Series X, plus PC." "I can't tell you right now about our most important feature, because we will have to save it for later. But the
gameplay mechanic built around those two worlds couldn't be fully realized on current-gen hardware. This is something that I think will distinguish our game from any other. It's also even
patented. So yeah, the game simply cannot work the same way on current-gen platforms. And that's why we are developing the game for Xbox Series X, plus PC."

https://www.gamespot.com/articles/x...ror-game-the-mediums-key-fe/1100-6476952/#nnn

For the example your for PS4/Xbox one one thing the last generation before of this has issue was with memory that with 512 MB was a pain in the ass so for the studios so
for example now games like for example Spiderman can use its memory as streaming pool which allows to improve a lot quantity of NPC and detail in the environment,
this before was possible yes but was easy? hell not, not even close.

Even some dream so high in the beginning than fails like that Paris full of NPCs in AC Unity, the thing the actual generation improve basically two things GPU and Memory but
thing like HDD and even the CPU (yeah more core easy to use but very weak) was the same basically since 2006 and that cause many problems in the moment to decide
what kind of thing your game can has.

That one of the reason of why publishers like EA and even Ubisoft will have titles only for the new gen because do a similar work in a XSX is cheaper and faster than do it in
Xbox one. Imagine you are an engineer of 343 and you had in charge to manipulate the AI for the NPC and you know you can put I don't know 10 NPCs in Xbox One and 40 NPCs
in XSX you can think doesn't matter I just do it.... well yeah is not so simple first because your QA department saw how the difficult increment a lot in the new version compare
the new version with old version and you just cannot change the damage of each enemy because that will not feel as the creative director wants.

That problem is impossible to solve not is not but cost money, time and also cut the liberty of the creative director because he is just cannot make crazy in his wants and even
some possible solution for X problem only can do in the new XSX because they need to use RT for very specific stuff.
 

TBiddy

Member
Precisely... it's in one of the Inocenceii videos, he explains why he is impressed with the PS5 SSD and the differences between it and Xbox's SSD with a nice animated illustration.

To be honest, I have absolutely no idea who Inocenceii is. I was asking you. Why do you think the XSX will be unable to "effectively saturate" the SSD they've chosen? Not enough memory? To little bandwidth? Poor choice of controller? I would assume that after spending 5-6 years on R&D for the console, it would be a small feat (all things considered) to create a console that would be able to saturate the SSD you've chosen.

In other news - it seems like ethomaz once again decided to leave a discussion after being unable to provide a source for his claims. At least he decided to heed the advice he previously got: "It's time to stop posting".
 

Bryank75

Banned
The E19 controller has a max speed of 3.7GB/s from what I’ve read and can support up to 2TB. Also, most likely MSFT customized it for their needs. On the other hand, someone on reddit made a good case for why the PS5 SSD controller is a custom variant of the more advanced e16 controller.
I'm just relaying what I've seen explained in the video's I've watched and then based my own position on the feedback dev's seem to be giving about how effective it is....

Of course I have my own biases too. I'd like to think the extra costs PlayStation incurred will actually result in a very tangible difference..... It would be very surprising if it didn't.
 

TBiddy

Member
I'm just relaying what I've seen explained in the video's I've watched and then based my own position on the feedback dev's seem to be giving about how effective it is....

Of course I have my own biases too. I'd like to think the extra costs PlayStation incurred will actually result in a very tangible difference..... It would be very surprising if it didn't.

Considering the SSD in the PS5 is about twice as fast, I'd say that's a very tangible difference. But I think it's important to note that just because the PS5 SSD is ridiculously fast, the XSX SSD is still extremely fast.
 

Bryank75

Banned
To be honest, I have absolutely no idea who Inocenceii is. I was asking you. Why do you think the XSX will be unable to "effectively saturate" the SSD they've chosen? Not enough memory? To little bandwidth? Poor choice of controller? I would assume that after spending 5-6 years on R&D for the console, it would be a small feat (all things considered) to create a console that would be able to saturate the SSD you've chosen.

In other news - it seems like ethomaz once again decided to leave a discussion after being unable to provide a source for his claims. At least he decided to heed the advice he previously got: "It's time to stop posting".
Here is his channel.. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDMF4SaMIIfltWQcLTrYMrw

Without me having privileged info, I can only guess why they didn't.... I suppose it all comes down to cost / benefit. They probably wanted the tflop crown more than the SSD one and estimated that it would benefit them more (which so far is correct).

The man-power, cost and trade-offs (opportunity cost) of spending extra time on something that they didn't think would benefit them optimally, just might have not seemed to be worth it.
 

TBiddy

Member
Here is his channel.. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDMF4SaMIIfltWQcLTrYMrw

Without me having privileged info, I can only guess why they didn't.... I suppose it all comes down to cost / benefit. They probably wanted the tflop crown more than the SSD one and estimated that it would benefit them more (which so far is correct).

The man-power, cost and trade-offs (opportunity cost) of spending extra time on something that they didn't think would benefit them optimally, just might have not seemed to be worth it.

I'll see if I can find the video in question, but I gotta say - it sounds very unlikely that Microsoft would be able to design an otherwise extremely powerful console, only to completely ignore the SSD they've selected.
 

Bryank75

Banned
Considering the SSD in the PS5 is about twice as fast, I'd say that's a very tangible difference. But I think it's important to note that just because the PS5 SSD is ridiculously fast, the XSX SSD is still extremely fast.
Yeah, that's kinda what I'm saying.... the xbox team may have said 'we can spend loads of time on the SSD and make it a bit faster or use that time and money on other areas'.....

They just didn't put that amount of importance on it. Having 'an SSD' is all most people will hear, they won't get into speeds.
 

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
Here is his channel.. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDMF4SaMIIfltWQcLTrYMrw

Without me having privileged info, I can only guess why they didn't.... I suppose it all comes down to cost / benefit. They probably wanted the tflop crown more than the SSD one and estimated that it would benefit them more (which so far is correct).

The man-power, cost and trade-offs (opportunity cost) of spending extra time on something that they didn't think would benefit them optimally, just might have not seemed to be worth it.
But where did this guy:

Just a guy who plays games so you don't have to. But of course, you're welcome to join :) Here you'll find reviews (of games), news, commentaries, and any other crazy nonsense that pops into my mind, enjoy :D Upload (goal) at least once a week during university, and twice a week any other time!

... get that from?

I think that's what TBiddy TBiddy is asking. Is it from some released info or just what some guy on YouTube is saying?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom