Support NeoGAF

[Monad]

More FH5 ingame shots (no HUD) from XSX Performance mode:

You can clearly see the aliasing being more prominent compared to Quality mode/PC on higher settings.

 

[Turk1993]

And here is the cockpit comparison, this was the only place in both games that the lighting was the closest. I will post some other screenshots of cockpit view in other lighting conditions from both games that do both games more justice. But man its hard to get the lighting matched in Forza Horizon 5 because of the lack of tod setting/control. Literally waited 20min to get the tod as close as possible. And this is not even the best lighting condition of both games but this will do it. For the cockpit view my choose would be 80% of the time the cockpits in GT7 just because of the better shaders and more finer detail. Both games had car models with better polygons than each other but GT7 had 90% of the time better materials and finer detail so i choose GT7 for the interiors.

Lexus RC F

Ferrari Laferarri

Ford GT

Mercedes-AMG C63s

 

[Turk1993]

And here are the best of GT7 that show some impressive lighting and material shaders
All gameplay btw

 

[adamsapple]

GT has the better interiors, clearly you can see the developers spent more time crafting those.

I, personally, never use the cockpit view in a racing game ever. I like a nice far-chase camera.

 

[Craig of War]

More FH5 ingame shots (no HUD) from XSX Performance mode:

You can clearly see the aliasing being more prominent compared to Quality mode/PC on higher settings.

I can't see anything lol

 

[Turk1993]

And here are the best of Forza Horizon 5 that show one of the better interiors

 

[adamsapple]

This one looks nice, but it looks like a Star Wars starfighter interior lol.

I can't see anything lol

 

[Craig of War]

This one looks nice, but it looks like a Star Wars starfighter interior lol.

 

[ethomaz]

And here is the cockpit comparison, this was the only place in both games that the lighting was the closest. I will post some other screenshots of cockpit view in other lighting conditions from both games that do both games more justice. But man its hard to get the lighting matched in Forza Horizon 5 because of the lack of tod setting/control. Literally waited 20min to get the tod as close as possible. And this is not even the best lighting condition of both games but this will do it. For the cockpit view my choose would be 80% of the time the cockpits in GT7 just because of the better shaders and more finer detail. Both games had car models with better polygons than each other but GT7 had 90% of the time better materials and finer detail so i choose GT7 for the interiors.

Lexus RC F

Ferrari Laferarri

Ford GT

Mercedes-AMG C63s

FH5 interior looks like toys.
Or maybe it is just the color palette.

And here are the best of Forza Horizon 5 that show one of the better interiors

Here is even more evident.

 

[ethomaz]

I can't see anything lol

Are you looking on mobile? If not open the pic in full screen… it will be even more evident if your monitor is 4k.

There is no way to not see the aliasing on back that is the easiest to spot.

 

[ethomaz]

I’m doing some research.
This is the PS App upload capture…

HDR (It only allow JPEG)

SDR (PNG)

Edit - I took some more pics with HDR but I forget to remove the HUB.

I think I will take only SDR PNG now.

 

[Neo_game]

The game use that LOD for ingame car model even in performance mode (native 4K and 60 fps) on a Series X:

The interior in GT7 and the bumper Lexus emblem is appalling low. It could be that FH5 has better scaling than GT7. Because the headlight in GT7 still has more detail than these shots and compared to PC max settings as well:

https://i.ibb.co/yspcYph/FH5vs-GT7-2-2.jpg

 

[Inviusx]

And here is the cockpit comparison, this was the only place in both games that the lighting was the closest. I will post some other screenshots of cockpit view in other lighting conditions from both games that do both games more justice. But man its hard to get the lighting matched in Forza Horizon 5 because of the lack of tod setting/control. Literally waited 20min to get the tod as close as possible. And this is not even the best lighting condition of both games but this will do it. For the cockpit view my choose would be 80% of the time the cockpits in GT7 just because of the better shaders and more finer detail. Both games had car models with better polygons than each other but GT7 had 90% of the time better materials and finer detail so i choose GT7 for the interiors.

Lexus RC F

Ferrari Laferarri

Ford GT

Mercedes-AMG C63s

Very hard to compare when the rendering engines are so different between games. I guess I have to lean towards GT7 as it looks less like a video game than FH5.

 

[Coulomb_Barrier]

This is the best graphics in a car game I've ever seen. Hands down.

Here's another one:



Looks like the best city racing I've seen. Before I get egg on my face again, are there other franchises with city racing that look as good as this?

One of the supreme things about GT7 is that sound and physics/controls though, sets a new benchmark.

 

[Markio128]

And here are the best of GT7 that show some impressive lighting and material shaders
All gameplay btw

Great shots fella and exactly how I see the game when I‘m playing, which hopefully gives a better understanding to those wondering why I seem to be more enamoured by GT7s visuals. The way the materials react to the lighting, the natural colours and shadowing, gives the game a greater sense of realism. PD have also massively improved the sense of speed by the use of motion blur. I’d say both games are top in their current class, visually, for different reasons.

 

[rodrigolfp]

And here is the cockpit comparison, this was the only place in both games that the lighting was the closest. I will post some other screenshots of cockpit view in other lighting conditions from both games that do both games more justice. But man its hard to get the lighting matched in Forza Horizon 5 because of the lack of tod setting/control. Literally waited 20min to get the tod as close as possible. And this is not even the best lighting condition of both games but this will do it. For the cockpit view my choose would be 80% of the time the cockpits in GT7 just because of the better shaders and more finer detail. Both games had car models with better polygons than each other but GT7 had 90% of the time better materials and finer detail so i choose GT7 for the interiors.

Lexus RC F

Ferrari Laferarri

Ford GT

Mercedes-AMG C63s

Tons of edges more visible on GT shots. FH5 higher poly or GT doesn't know to use some tessellation?

 

[M1chl]

And here are the best of Forza Horizon 5 that show one of the better interiors

With these shots, there is an obvious problem with FH5 and it's those mirror reflection, they are clearly overdone. I have around 150 hours in the game and it really bothers me.

 

[Markio128]

Tons of edges more visible on GT shots. FH5 higher poly or GT doesn't know to use some tessellation?

One thing to consider is that you can move your head around in the GT7 cockpit, however, it is a static view in FH5.

 

[SLB1904]

Tons of edges more visible on GT shots. FH5 higher poly or GT doesn't know to use some tessellation?

You watching in a small screen. Watch in a proper high res screen.

 

[Coulomb_Barrier]

You absolutely can get paint as reflective

Ok maybe I was a bit off on that, at first glance it looked way too reflective. The average car I see on the road in reality is not half as buffed to be that shiny.

 

[MidGenRefresh]

One thing to consider is that you can move your head around in the GT7 cockpit, however, it is a static view in FH5.

?

You can freely move left and right in cockpit view during gameplay.

On top of that you can inspect interior in great detail in Forzavista mode with animations for car start-up etc. This has been a thing since Forza Motorsport 4:

 

[RoyBatty]

There are some AC + CSP shots:

 

[BigLee74]

One thing to consider is that you can move your head around in the GT7 cockpit, however, it is a static view in FH5.

Erm, no it’s not. You’ve obviously never played it.

 

[BigLee74]

I think Turk1993 is about the only guy you can trust in this forum. He plays all the games, and has no obvious affiliation or agenda. Other folk can’t see past their own console (it’s funny seeing all the old names resurface with this thread’s resurrection).

I’m personally not a big sim fan, but I do like a good looking car game, and I think they all look great these days!

 

[adamsapple]

There are some AC + CSP shots:

AC as in Assetto Corsa?

Great shots.

 

[Loope]

GT has fantastic interiors.Although you can see the polys,mainly on the Merc wheel, the materials and lighting are top notch. Also both games go for different directions, one is arcade and has a more lively colour palette that doesn't work well with some PBR materials. When Forza Motorsport is out, we'll have more appropriate comparisons, because on a track the environment is completely different and they tend to use realistic lighting.

That said, to me, AC with mods looks the more realistic game.

 

[adamsapple]

I think Turk1993 is about the only guy you can trust in this forum. He plays all the games, and has no obvious affiliation or agenda. Other folk can’t see past their own console (it’s funny seeing all the old names resurface with this thread’s resurrection).

I’m personally not a big sim fan, but I do like a good looking car game, and I think they all look great these days!

I'm just here to spread some FH5 love

 

[rodrigolfp]

You watching in a small screen. Watch in a proper high res screen.

Lol. Bigger screen made the edges bigger.

 

[Turk1993]

ACC (PC) vs GT7 (PS5)
All gameplay
This one will be big so im gonna post it in different parts, and there is even more to come (different tracks, weather, cars,...)
Part 1

 

[Turk1993]

Part 2

 

[benzy]

Would be more interesting to see ACC on PS5 with the next-gen patch compared to pS5 GT7.

GT7

 

[rodrigolfp]

Part 2

ACC cars are in another league.

 

[Feel Like I'm On 42]

More FH5 ingame shots (no HUD) from XSX Performance mode:

You can clearly see the aliasing being more prominent compared to Quality mode/PC on higher settings.

These shots don't look that good to begin with imo

 

[Feel Like I'm On 42]

Gran Turismo clearly wins graphically, but Horizon is more suited for me. I don't want to invest enough to get into a simulation racer.

It's the least sim, sim racer I've played in terms of accessibility. It has that perfect blend of pick up and play or spend time tweaking things. Don't write it off!

 

[Feel Like I'm On 42]

Anyone here own both Assetto Corsa next gen and gt7? If so, what are the key differences?

 

[Feel Like I'm On 42]

Part 2

Those look quite nice. What platform?

 

[Craig of War]

Are you looking on mobile? If not open the pic in full screen… it will be even more evident if your monitor is 4k.

There is no way to not see the aliasing on back that is the easiest to spot.

This is what im seeing lol i literally cannot see the picture

 

[Feel Like I'm On 42]

Those look quite nice. What platform?

Nvm ...PC no way will ps5 look close to that

 

[nemiroff]

You can freely move left and right in cockpit view during gameplay.

And not only that, there's also a dynamic camera called "drift camera" in FH5 (also in FH4 btw), but it's not enabled by default. It's not only for drifting, I'd say it's almost mandatory for normal racing as well, it's awesome. There are a lot of parameters for it so just tune it to your liking.

 

[SLB1904]

fuck me

 

[Balducci30]

GT7’s lights and materials look better - everything else is forza probably - but the lights and materials look amazing how do they do that makes it look super real

 

[Craig of War]

GT7’s lights and materials look better - everything else is forza probably - but the lights and materials look amazing how do they do that makes it look super real

It their ForzaTech engine it also use on Flight Simulator 2020 and it looks great.
Gran Turismo really need to up their game on the environment detail it looks really soft to me when comparing to other racing game.

 

[Sebmugi]

Some detail shoot with RT on

 

[Three]

Lol. Bigger screen made the edges bigger.

Are you mixing up the games then?

 

[rodrigolfp]

Are you mixing up the games then?

Am I?

 

[Utherellus]

Forza Motorsport 7 was so underrated. on PC Ultra it looks amazing for 2017 game and races easily with competitors.

 

[ethomaz]

Forza Motorsport 7 was so underrated. on PC Ultra it looks amazing for 2017 game and races easily with competitors.

All games are underrated if you use PC Ultra.

 

[rodrigolfp]

Forza Motorsport 7 was so underrated. on PC Ultra it looks amazing for 2017 game and races easily with competitors.

Dat shadows casting on Forza. Lol at the classic potato physics extra simcade of GT.

 

[SLB1904]

Dat shadows casting on Forza. Lol at the classic potato physics extra simcade of GT.

Gt physics shits all over forza and its not even funny

 

[rodrigolfp]

Gt physics shits all over forza and its not even funny

Especially the collision physics like in the video, right?