I don't think you read the OP.Hardcore. Why is that on top of the pedestal? Why is there even a pedestal? Why can't I enjoy the product I payed for without being called a casual or a console pleb? It's all gaming so it's all good right? It's like that kid who got the newest toy in grade school and maked all the other kids feel like shit for not having it. It's all pretty immature.
He's not listing a binary choice. It's also been stated many times that he wishes he used the word Enthusiast in the OP title, rather than Hardcore.