Support NeoGAF

[thelurkinghorror]

They're no longer capable of delivering, and haven't been for a long time. Your best bet is probably the studio Drew Karpyshyn is at, Archetype Entertainment, and their upcoming Mass Effect spiritual successor called Exodus.

If my memory is right, this was cancelled some weeks ago…

 

[StreetsofBeige]

If my memory is right, this was cancelled some weeks ago…

Never heard of this game or studio, but I googled it and dont see anything about a cancellation.

Did you mean this game instead?

Former Mass Effect Lead's New Sci-Fi Game Cancelled, Developer Shuts Down

Humanoid Origin announces closure

www.pushsquare.com

 

[RJMacready73]

Make attractive characters like this lady back in games.

Can't be having attractive feminine women in western DEI infected games, it'll make the fatties and blokes in dresses feel bad

 

[Sentenza]

If my memory is right, this was cancelled some weeks ago…

Nah, that was ANOTHER Mass-Effect-inspired game in development by OTHER Bioware's former employees.

 

[StreetsofBeige]

Hit under 4,000 last night.

 

[Humdinger]

Take this fwiw, but another anonymous Bioware insider reports that "over 3 million" have been sold at this point. JT, the channel author, states that he verified that the reporter is a long-time Bioware employee. He says that the team's "ambitious" expectation was to sell 10 million in the first 3 months, and so the 3 million sales numbers are seen as a "disappointment," internally. Which seems odd to me.

edit: see my post a few entries below, where this report gets amended/corrected. Apparently these are projected sales, not actual sales.


He goes on to talk about the conflicted internal atmosphere in the company. Makes the point that there are a lot of great people at Bioware trying to make good games, but that people who enable the modern ideological stuff are in leadership and it's hard to speak up. Fears of layoffs on the horizon.

 

[Trogdor1123]

Take this fwiw, but another anonymous Bioware insider reports significantly higher sales figures than expected: "well over 3 million" at this point. The channel author states that he verified that the reporter is a long-time Bioware employee. He adds that the team's "very ambitious" expectation was to sell 10 million in the first 3 months, so the 3 million sales numbers are seen as a disappointment. Which seems odd to me.

He goes on to talk about the conflicted internal atmosphere in the company and fears about layoffs on the horizon.

3 million isn’t too bad, is it? Didn’t inquisition take years to hit 10 million?

 

[Humdinger]

3 million isn’t too bad, is it? Didn’t inquisition take years to hit 10 million?

3 million sold in 6 weeks isn't bad at all. Granted, they need a lot more than that to break even (6 to 8 million? hard to say), but it's not a bad start. It's certainly better than I expected.

It could be "shipped to retailers" rather than "sold to consumers," but that's probably how most companies tally sales.

 

[Timeless One]

If my memory is right, this was cancelled some weeks ago…

That was Humanoid Origin, led by Mass Effect trilogy director, Casey Hudson.

 

[StreetsofBeige]

Hit 3,400-ish last night.

Will hit the 2,000s soon.

 

[Humdinger]

Something about that 3 million figure doesn't add up. It's not just the Steam user count being low. It's the fact that the game was selling for $50 - down nearly a third in price, less than a month after release - at all major retailers. I'm not just talking Black Friday sales. This was before Black Friday, and after Black Friday, continuously. It's still listed at $50 everywhere - amazon, Best Buy, Walmart, Target, etc.

If a game is selling well, why would you slash prices so drastically and so quickly? That seriously undercuts profit and extends the time needed to break even.

However, it would help to explain why it sold 3 million (if it did). Many/most of those copies were sold at $50, not $70.

edit: never mind, the original report was corrected. Apparently, the 3 million figure is projected, not actual sales (see below).

 

[Hawk The Slayer]

Not surprised to see even 3 million being bad for them if it actually is at 3 million that is. If Rebirth's 3 million was considered below expectation than 3 million for Veilguard would be even worse since Rebirth being a eastern game and having tons of reuse assets definitely cost less budget. Plus Rebirth is going to have much better leg and word of mouth compared to Veilguard so it's not looking good for them even in the long term.

 

[MayauMiao]

If 3 million is good, why they/them have no plans for DLC?

 

[pulicat]

3 million sales numbers is certainly bullshit.

Dragon's Dogma 2 that placed far higher on sales chart in the NA, Europe, and Asia than Veilguard is barely above 3m. Even FF7 Rebirth that's selling below 3m is charting higher than Veilguard across the globe.

Veilguard only did slightly better than Outlaws thanks to the steam.

 

[Humdinger]

Clarification to the video I posted above As always, take this fwiw; you're free to ignore it 'grifter' nonsense if you like.

Synopsis: One of JT's other Bioware sources, to whom he had spoken earlier, contacted him after the last video - the one reporting "well over 3 million sales." He clarified that the 3 million figure was "not actual sales but instead the internal projections of lifetime sales ... if everything goes to plan, as of right now."

The actual sales are currently at "less than 1.5 million." (consumers, not retail)

Which makes more sense. Although if I'm being skeptical, it seems like an underestimate for lifetime sales. If you're almost at 1.5 million now, getting to over 3 million in a lifetime wouldn't be at all hard, and I could see it getting to 5 or 6 as the game is discounted. But what do I know.

If they're truly projecting "over 3 million" lifetime sales, based on what they're seeing now, that is bad. That has to be way under what would be required to break even.

 

[Mister Wolf]

Clarification to the video I posted above As always, take this fwiw; you're free to ignore it 'grifter' nonsense if you like.

Synopsis: One of JT's other Bioware sources, to whom he had spoken earlier, contacted him after the last video - the one reporting "well over 3 million sales." He clarified that the 3 million figure was "not actual sales but instead the internal projections of lifetime sales ... if everything goes to plan, as of right now."

The actual sales are currently at "less than 1.5 million."

Which makes more sense. Although it would seem if you're at 1.5 million now, getting to "well over 3 million" lifetime sales would be easy, especially the game is discounted. Seems like you could hit 5 or 6 easily, but what do I know.

I never believed that 3 million. The lack of chest pounding announcement of sales and huge price cut sale in less than 2 months tell the tale.

 

[Skifi28]

If 3 million is good, why they/them have no plans for DLC?

It's too good, they no longer need money and can retire living the rest of their lives in luxury.

 

[LectureMaster]

Game's on 35% off sale. If anything, it's desperation.

 

[Humdinger]

I never believed that 3 million. The lack of chest pounding announcement of sales and huge price cut sale in less than 2 months tell the tale.

Yeah, I don't think most people did. If you look at the comments for that video, just about everyone is saying "no way it's 3 million."

 

[StereoVsn]

Clarification to the video I posted above As always, take this fwiw; you're free to ignore it 'grifter' nonsense if you like.

Synopsis: One of JT's other Bioware sources, to whom he had spoken earlier, contacted him after the last video - the one reporting "well over 3 million sales." He clarified that the 3 million figure was "not actual sales but instead the internal projections of lifetime sales ... if everything goes to plan, as of right now."

The actual sales are currently at "less than 1.5 million." (consumers, not retail)

Which makes more sense. Although if I'm being skeptical, it seems like an underestimate for lifetime sales. If you're almost at 1.5 million now, getting to over 3 million in a lifetime wouldn't be at all hard, and I could see it getting to 5 or 6 as the game is discounted. But what do I know.

If they're truly projecting "over 3 million" lifetime sales, based on what they're seeing now, that is bad. That has to be way under what would be required to break even.

Now that makes a ton more sense. 1.5 mil on all platforms could have been done and 3 million lifetime (say over next 5 years) is possible.

That’s still EA losing money in the game though and we are not talking Hollywood accounting.

 

[GHG]

Game's on 35% off sale. If anything, it's desperation.

This is what I did instead.

Far better value.

 

[Humdinger]

Now that makes a ton more sense. 1.5 mil on all platforms could have been done and 3 million lifetime (say over next 5 years) is possible.

That’s still EA losing money in the game though and we are not talking Hollywood accounting.

Sounds like their original projection was for the game to sell 10 million over its lifetime. That's not working out so well...

 

[LectureMaster]

This is what I did instead.

Far better value.

Thanks for the heads up! Gonna grab DA2 to complete my collection as well. I remember we complained it wasn't on sale during BF.

 

[Kacho]

Game's on 35% off sale. If anything, it's desperation.

Holy shit!!!

 

[LectureMaster]

Holy shit!!!

Gonna buy it?

 

[Kacho]

Gonna buy it?

 

[Zacfoldor]

Clarification to the video I posted above As always, take this fwiw; you're free to ignore it 'grifter' nonsense if you like.

Synopsis: One of JT's other Bioware sources, to whom he had spoken earlier, contacted him after the last video - the one reporting "well over 3 million sales." He clarified that the 3 million figure was "not actual sales but instead the internal projections of lifetime sales ... if everything goes to plan, as of right now."

The actual sales are currently at "less than 1.5 million." (consumers, not retail)

Which makes more sense. Although if I'm being skeptical, it seems like an underestimate for lifetime sales. If you're almost at 1.5 million now, getting to over 3 million in a lifetime wouldn't be at all hard, and I could see it getting to 5 or 6 as the game is discounted. But what do I know.

If they're truly projecting "over 3 million" lifetime sales, based on what they're seeing now, that is bad. That has to be way under what would be required to break even.

If that is true, and I really hope AND believe that it is.....

 

[Gaiff]

Clarification to the video I posted above As always, take this fwiw; you're free to ignore it 'grifter' nonsense if you like.

Synopsis: One of JT's other Bioware sources, to whom he had spoken earlier, contacted him after the last video - the one reporting "well over 3 million sales." He clarified that the 3 million figure was "not actual sales but instead the internal projections of lifetime sales ... if everything goes to plan, as of right now."

The actual sales are currently at "less than 1.5 million." (consumers, not retail)

Which makes more sense. Although if I'm being skeptical, it seems like an underestimate for lifetime sales. If you're almost at 1.5 million now, getting to over 3 million in a lifetime wouldn't be at all hard, and I could see it getting to 5 or 6 as the game is discounted. But what do I know.

If they're truly projecting "over 3 million" lifetime sales, based on what they're seeing now, that is bad. That has to be way under what would be required to break even.

Yeah, bullshit. 3M lifetime sales projection lmao? What nonsense is this? Those bozos could at least make up shit that is believable.

 

[StreetsofBeige]

Yeah, bullshit. 3M lifetime sales projection lmao? What nonsense is this? Those bozos could at least make up shit that is believable.

Based on Steam CCU, that 3M sales claim seemed like BS from the get go.

But 3M lifetime sales projection? That cant be right either. No way it'd be that low.

 

[Plague Doctor]

Clarification to the video I posted above As always, take this fwiw; you're free to ignore it 'grifter' nonsense if you like.

Synopsis: One of JT's other Bioware sources, to whom he had spoken earlier, contacted him after the last video - the one reporting "well over 3 million sales." He clarified that the 3 million figure was "not actual sales but instead the internal projections of lifetime sales ... if everything goes to plan, as of right now."

The actual sales are currently at "less than 1.5 million." (consumers, not retail)

Which makes more sense. Although if I'm being skeptical, it seems like an underestimate for lifetime sales. If you're almost at 1.5 million now, getting to over 3 million in a lifetime wouldn't be at all hard, and I could see it getting to 5 or 6 as the game is discounted. But what do I know.

If they're truly projecting "over 3 million" lifetime sales, based on what they're seeing now, that is bad. That has to be way under what would be required to break even.

I mean there is a reason in less than a week of launch they cancelled all DLC and moved the team to ME5 with a strange statement that "Mass Effect will have serious writing blah blah blah."

There is a lot to be gleened regarding sales projections from the first couple days of launch + presales. They more or less know the ceiling of lifetime sales (barring any outside and extraordinary event) by then and it wasn't good.

So, drop all post launch support like DLCs and switch immediately to the next thing. The curious thing was the statement about ME5 like they knew the current impression of DA:V was damaging the studio's narrative writing chops.

Yeah, DA:V is an abject failure in regards to what EA was wanting and we get more circumstantial proof by the week.

 

[Denton]

This is what I did instead.

Far better value.

So annoying that Origins and DAII have no controller support and remaster treatment.

1.5 million sold for DAV is what I would have expected according to numbers in relation to other games like DD2.

DAV lost EA shit ton of money.

 

[Humdinger]

But 3M lifetime sales projection? That cant be right either. No way it'd be that low.

Agreed. It's hard to trust this report, too, because of that figure. If they are at nearly 1.5 million after 6 weeks, they would certainly be able to reach a lot higher than 3 million during its lifetime. I mean, that's 10 years of sales, at ever-lower discounts.

 

[DonkeyPunchJr]

Agreed. It's hard to trust this report, too, because of that figure. If they are at nearly 1.5 million after 6 weeks, they would certainly be able to reach a lot higher than 3 million during its lifetime. I mean, that's 10 years of sales, at ever-lower discounts.

I don’t think it’s that hard to believe that a single player game with no DLC would get half its total lifetime sales in the first 6 weeks.

 

[Humdinger]

I don’t think it’s that hard to believe that a single player game with no DLC would get half its total lifetime sales in the first 6 weeks.

I don't know, man, that just seems too low. I know sales are front loaded, but a lifetime is a long time. We're talking 10 years of selling the game at $50, then $40, then $30, then $20, then $10... Surely they will be able to hit 5 or 6 million copies over a lifetime.
.
But then, I'm no sales guru. I could be wrong. It just seems to me that 3 million lifetime is too low (actually, the original report said "well over 3 million").

 

[EDMIX]

I don’t think it’s that hard to believe that a single player game with no DLC would get half its total lifetime sales in the first 6 weeks.

I mean it greatly depends

I don't know, man, that just seems too low. I know sales are front loaded, but a lifetime is a long time. We're talking 10 years of selling the game at $50, then $40, then $30, then $20, then $10... Surely they will be able to hit 5 or 6 million copies over a lifetime.

Well the best selling in the series did like 12 million in terms of Dragon Age Inquisition, but that seems to be a deep favorite and not the series norm, as in we can't expect 12 million cause that just happened once and not much really was around DAI outside of people talking about the gay bulls lol but in 2014, most didn't really give a shit tbh.

So I think hitting 5 or 4 million can be done, anything more is a massive maybe.


With deep sales, some next gen updates (like PS6), maybe.

But then, I'm no sales guru. I could be wrong. It just seems to me that 3 million lifetime is too low (actually, the original report said "well over 3 million").

I thought that too, but that is the sales of the very first Dragon Age, it was around 3 million.

Dragon Age 1 did 3 million

Dragon Age 3 did 12 million

So I don't know if doing over 3 million is too low, that is ballpark what the IP is used to, anything beyond that is a big question mark at this point.

 

[Monjiro]

They could make characters beutification mod. Story would still suck, but it would be more pleasant to suffer through

 

[stevish]

Is it on EA play pro? Wonder if they include any of that in numbers

 

[Humdinger]

I thought that too, but that is the sales of the very first Dragon Age, it was around 3 million.

Dragon Age 1 did 3 million

Dragon Age 3 did 12 million

So I don't know if doing over 3 million is too low, that is ballpark what the IP is used to, anything beyond that is a big question mark at this point.

I didn't realize DA:O only did 3 million lifetime. That's a shame, given that it's the best in the series. The budget was much lower back then, so hopefully it turned a profit.

Is it on EA play pro? Wonder if they include any of that in numbers

Yes, I believe it is. I'm not sure how EA handles those numbers.

*

Hey, I figured out how Veilguard ends up selling lots of copies. A decade from now, it becomes a cult classic, and people buy it up because they want to see Taash and barves and how retarded we had become as a culture. ;p

 

[Chuck Berry]

 

[Hookshot]

Hermione in the new Harry Potter show.

 

[Giallo Corsa]

Beautiful, stunning, brave and also, totally a woman.

 

[AyraSutoraifu]

Mother of god… i cannot tell which one is a woman, man or a dna reject.
"Hi AyraSutoraifu, wanna join us for diner?
…
Nah, i'm good."

 

[Madflavor]

Fuck dude, some people get the shittiest cards deal to them in life.

 

[StreetsofBeige]

Isnt it funny how the craziest looking people sit together?

The farther back the table you look, the more normal looking the people.

And at the way back, two normal looking guys not part of the group.

 

[DonkeyPunchJr]

The term “male pattern baldness” is offensive to trans women

 

[BehemothBlade]

So, one and a half months and this is the sales update

Dragon Age The Veilguard Head Won't Reveal Sales Numbers Of Game - Gameranx

Dragon Age The Veilguard has been out for a while now, and it's unclear how the game is doing sales-wise, even when asking the team about it!

gameranx.com

This is a bomb.

 

[DonkeyPunchJr]

Looks like the Christmas Break/Steam Sale bump has concluded and it has resumed its decline into hell where it belongs.