• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hogwarts Legacy Is Currently The Best Selling Game On Steam

Moneal

Member
I see what you mean. There are some similarities to Souls games but I guess not enough to look exciting for the hardcore lol...

I saw a guy on Twitter sharing a video of the combat and saying "this looks like ass lol", while others would basically say "looks like HP combat in an HP game. that's good!".

I will say there are high-level duels in the books and movies (Voldemort vs. Dumbledore in book/movie 5 comes to mind, and there was also a bit of Minerva vs. Snape in book 7), but that's beyond the level of a 5th year student.
Yep combat here looks and should be more like chamber of secrets or half blood prince Harry vs Malfoy.
 

GymWolf

Member
i bought this game to protest climate change
giphy.gif
 

Rayderism

Member
So, is era like normalphobic or something? Is that it? Isn't that just as bad as being transphobic or homophobic?

Anyway, I've already said before that I bought the game because it looks like it will be good, not for agendas or anything else. I don't even consider woke agendas when buying any video game. Personally I like to pretend all that woke stuff doesn't exist, even when it's being shoved in my face. I just sigh, roll my eyes and move on, not fly into rages over it.
 

phant0m

Member
So, is era like normalphobic or something? Is that it? Isn't that just as bad as being transphobic or homophobic?

Anyway, I've already said before that I bought the game because it looks like it will be good, not for agendas or anything else. I don't even consider woke agendas when buying any video game. Personally I like to pretend all that woke stuff doesn't exist, even when it's being shoved in my face. I just sigh, roll my eyes and move on, not fly into rages over it.
if being white, cisgendered and straight is "normal" then yes. any attempt to subvert or provide an alternative to "the community"s desires makes you a bigoted piece of shit.

proclaim you support their rights and condemn Rowling's views?

not good enough. if you still buy a game that gives her $2, you're a piece of shit.

you vote for progressive politicians that support them and their policy goals?

not good enough. if you still buy a game that gives her $2, you're a piece of shit.

you stand up for transpeople at home, at work, at school?

not good enough. if you still buy a game that gives her $2, you're a piece of shit.

you must obey like a good boy or you will get slapped on the snout with a label that says TRANSPHOBE. boycott all products that they demand. they say jump, your boots best be off the ground unless you're asking how high. it's not exclusive to REEEE either. any place that has a significant trans "community" is extremely hostile to straight, white, cisgendered people. if you can pass the purity tests, then you're ok. for now. just don't make any missteps, and don't you DARE have a thought of your own.

if this is their way of building allies and a movement, i wish them the best of luck. sad part is, like most wide communities these people are outliers. the transpeople i know in real life do not act this way. shame the extremists can't see how they are hurting their cause by pushing away "imperfect" supporters.
 
Last edited:

Ghost23

Member
For me, it's the opposite. The game already seems to be pulling from the souls formula with it's lock on and dodge rolls. I'd prefer something more unique rather than just "it's Dark Souls but there's only spells". Hopefully the end product ends up offering something more unique.

I agree with the rest of what you said about the clash of actual videogame enjoyers vs. HP fans.
If it makes you feel better, many of the previews, including the likes of IGN, actually said the combat was one of the best parts of the game they played. It’s more aligned with a combo fighter mixed in with Dark Souls. I would wait until you get actual opinions on Monday before making your decision.

Crap, 9 years old son and 12 years old daughter wants to play this. Not sure now lol, hopefully there is an easy mode for them

There is both an easy mode and a story mode difficulty so you can just enjoy the world and story
 
Lots of refunds incoming on Feb 11th
Not lot's of refunds, I can see a forspoken situation where it sells really well out the gate but depending on the quality will have legs or not. Harry Potter isn't an automatic success. Smaller IP than Avengers and that failed due to quality. Lets see the out the gates reviews.
 
So is that reset ban on talking or even mentioning the game indefinite, or did they actually add an expiration date for when people can talk about it there?

Also the ban is confusing me, didn't some staff from the game come out against JK? And she has nothing to do with it?

So why would they ban discussion in the first place when...
 

Diogodx

Neo Member
So is that reset ban on talking or even mentioning the game indefinite, or did they actually add an expiration date for when people can talk about it there?

Also the ban is confusing me, didn't some staff from the game come out against JK? And she has nothing to do with it?

So why would they ban discussion in the first place when...
You can't expect rational behavior from crazy people.

I think it is funny to post their craziness here but I don't think it's a reason for so much discussion.
 

TheRyzzl

Neo Member
So is that reset ban on talking or even mentioning the game indefinite, or did they actually add an expiration date for when people can talk about it there?

Also the ban is confusing me, didn't some staff from the game come out against JK? And she has nothing to do with it?

So why would they ban discussion in the first place when...
It’s permanent. Also since JK gets royalties from the HP license you’re(according to them) helping her fund donations to anti trans establishments.
 
It’s permanent. Also since JK gets royalties from the HP license you’re(according to them) helping her fund donations to anti trans establishments.

It's permanent???

So why only this game? Why not ban all games connected too her then?

Strange people over there. I guess any future re-releases will be banned to.

Except...aren't other people who they say are anti-trans still allowed to have their games talked about? Why is JK the exception specifically?

Yeah, I guess I'm just not going to understand their mindset on this one.

You can't expect rational behavior from crazy people.

Might be more than crazy based on that locked post I read from Bdubz
 

Handel

Member
It's permanent???

So why only this game? Why not ban all games connected too her then?

Strange people over there. I guess any future re-releases will be banned to.

Except...aren't other people who they say are anti-trans still allowed to have their games talked about? Why is JK the exception specifically?

Yeah, I guess I'm just not going to understand their mindset on this one.



Might be more than crazy based on that locked post I read from Bdubz
Reee has made Rowling their #1 enemy, might as well be Hitler for them since you're marred by any sort of connection no matter if it's indirect.

They're going to to vilify millions for wanting to play a game using one of the most beloved and popular IP on the planet, that was important to many peoples childhoods, because their hatred of one woman is that powerful.
 

krumble

Member
Didn't need to re-activate my account over here as always left it active, was banned over there since late 2021 as I was accused of bigotry and normalising hate speak or something stupid. Had just lurked after that, but the complete removal of any Hogwarts talk was too much for me, so was glad to see free speech is still a thing here, was wondering if I would face the same thing here because other reliable forums are a thing of the past.
I was cheered up a lot by the meme competition thread and seeing the libtards over at era so triggered and banning even mention of the game actually pushed me to preorder the digital deluxe edition today, I was going to wait for reviews, but instant-gaming provided me my series x key and it's all preloaded ready for the 7th.. probably go back to lurking again lol
I think the sales will be huge and as a gay guy with multiple disabilities and many REAL trans friends I've know from decades I have to say I'm team TURF. Most of my transexual friends are to be Frank, the blue haired freaks have done a disservice to all the progress made by the real trans community for acceptance that they fought for And had to fight hard, but then again my friends look like women, not men in dresses, anyway should probably shut up low before I'm banned here
More excited for the game and the planned sharing of lovely screen shots to annoy people that will come with it 😂
 
Last edited:
Refunded dead space remake because I had issues with the controls on my PC. Bought this game, haven't looked at any real gameplay but excited to experience it with little to no knowledge of the game. Also I bought this game in the name of science.
 
Last edited:

Windle Poons

Made a crappy phPBB forum once ... once.
It’s only the shitty mods on reeeeee that are doing this. I can’t give percentages but X% of the mods over there will buy and enjoy the game and just never mention it whilst banning anyone who attempts to mention the game whilst keeping their own heads down.
 
Last edited:

GymWolf

Member
What about the fact that she just helped to save a bunch of women from the taliban? How is that anti trans?
The more real women around the world, the less opportunity for trans women to find good men to marry, how is that positive for them?

It's all connected dude.
 
The more real women around the world, the less opportunity for trans women to find good men to marry, how is that positive for them?

It's all connected dude.
The few times I’ve had straight guys I know say dumb shit like “trans women are women”, my first question is always, “So you’d date one then, right?”

The colour always drains from their face and the stammering starts.
 

Freeman76

Member
It’s only the shitty mods on reeeeee that are doing this. I can’t give percentages but X% of the mods over there will buy and enjoy the game and just never mention it whilst banning anyone who attempts to mention the game whilst keeping their own heads down.

Its the entire forum thats like that not just the mods
 

Makoto-Yuki

Gold Member
It’s only the shitty mods on reeeeee that are doing this. I can’t give percentages but X% of the mods over there will buy and enjoy the game and just never mention it whilst banning anyone who attempts to mention the game whilst keeping their own heads down.
I don't post on Ree but I was curious to see what their take was on Hogwarts so had a look a while back. There was a thread where a surprising amount of people were saying that they were going to buy it but it was shut down by a mod because of some bullshit reason because it seems they didn't like how many people were bringing up Hogwarts lol

i'll see if i can find it.

they will most definitely have a lot of people over there playing it but it seems that they won't be allowed to talk about it without getting banned :messenger_tears_of_joy:

edit: here it is

 
Last edited by a moderator:

YeulEmeralda

Linux User
Harry Potter has always been shitty isekai for 11 year old girls but everyone wants to relive their childhood I guess?


Ridiculous how a children's game is the battleground for culture wars.
 

Certinty

Member
I don't post on Ree but I was curious to see what their take was on Hogwarts so had a look a while back. There was a thread where a surprising amount of people were saying that they were going to buy it but it was shut down by a mod because of some bullshit reason because it seems they didn't like how many people were bringing up Hogwarts lol

i'll see if i can find it.

they will most definitely have a lot of people over there playing it but it seems that they won't be allowed to talk about it without getting banned :messenger_tears_of_joy:

edit: here it is

[/URL]
If I weren’t already perma banned on Era I would seriously refuse to believe it was a real place from all I’ve read on here. Dear God…
 
Harry Potter has always been shitty isekai for 11 year old girls but everyone wants to relive their childhood I guess?


Ridiculous how a children's game is the battleground for culture wars.
Sure. One of the most popular IP in history, with book sales that are only behind the bible (literally, its the best selling series of all time) is just shitty isekai (and anyone using that word is much stranger than the people excited about a game) for 11 year old girls.

It’s perfectly fine not to be interested, byt some comments I’ve seen are ridiculous.

“No way this os bigger than Spider-Man or Zelda”.
(It is, in fact I think people would be shocked how low Zelda sales are aside from BotW).

Look how awful the combat is!
(Shows a video of someone ignoring all of their spells and just using the same one over and over)

The fact is the game looks really good, and the HP fandom eclipses those of Spider-Man, Bethesda, God of War or any other franchise most can name. Fantastic Beasts failed because they were awful, and the last one released mid pandemic.

If this game is good, not great just good, it will sell 10m in the first week. I wouldn’t be surprised if pre-sales are enough for them to internally green light part 2.
 

Hot5pur

Member
Any early impressions of this?
From what gameplay I've seen it looks very middling. Also not a Potter fan, but I really hope this is good because I gotz gaming itches that need scratching.
 

Holammer

Member


Troy Leavitt made a nice little video discussing the upcoming release and his involvement in the development.
Some interesting insights into gamedev and how Avalanche bypass gaming media by communicating with the fans directly. That's a good model more developers should learn from.

Resetera is approaching thoughtcrime territory with all this constant banning of users and threads for simply mentioning the title of a fucking video game.
If I had an account there I would slyly suggest I was very excited about the Game-that-must-not-be-named.
 

NeoIkaruGAF

Gold Member
It's permanent???

So why only this game? Why not ban all games connected too her then?

Strange people over there. I guess any future re-releases will be banned to.

Except...aren't other people who they say are anti-trans still allowed to have their games talked about? Why is JK the exception specifically?

Yeah, I guess I'm just not going to understand their mindset on this one.



Might be more than crazy based on that locked post I read from Bdubz
Don’t look for any traces of coherence in that place. Some people there are actual loons, some others are just blatant trolls, and most are internet bullies abusing the power they have in their little backyard and enjoying it very very much. They’ve found their little niche where they can always be right and abuse anyone they deem not right based on ever-shifting unspoken rules and double standards.
One has to wonder if the Era buyout was a money laundering scheme. Owning an alleged video game forum and allowing the moderation to ban any discussion about one of the most anticipated games of the year that belongs to one of the biggest IPs of the 21st century, makes less commercial sense than anything I can think of.

I just hope the game is good. I won’t be there at full price, but if it’s good, I may get it later.
 

Unrivaled18

Neo Member
Oh man, I thought the Harry Potter thing was bad.

There is a thread up on resetera where they are talking about transgender athletes being excluded from sporting events. If you mention that males converting to female have an unfair advantage, apparently this is extremely transphobic and an automatic permanent ban.

Wtf, I support transgender people 100% but come the hell on. If Usain Bolt tomorrow decides to be a woman, and crushes all the world records next month, are these people seriously fine with this scenario? This is some looney batshit crazy thinking. In what world is saying this would be unfair to women transphobic?

They cry about bullying to transgender people, but any time anyone disagrees with them they are labeled a bigot and they bully them into getting a permanent ban.

I honestly can't tell who is worse between the very far right bullies who are completely against transgender/lgbt people, or the far left bullies on resetera who attack anyone who has an opinion that differs with them. The two sides are more similar than they would like to believe.
 
Last edited:
Reee will put a case against JK in the ICC for genocide if it sells that much in 1 month!
Every copy sold is the literal murder of a Trans Person. JKR worse than Hitler, Stalin, Ze-Dong, and Pol Pot together.
She must be hung for....
*Checks notes*
Advocating for women's rights!
Sentence to be carried out by the first person on Era to leave their basement, touch grass, and see sunlight.
Relax Jo, you've got time.
 
Oh man, I thought the Harry Potter thing was bad.

There is a thread up on resetera where they are talking about transgender athletes being excluded from sporting events. If you mention that males converting to female have an unfair advantage, apparently this is extremely transphobic and an automatic permanent ban.

Wtf, I support transgender people 100% but come the hell on. If Usain Bolt tomorrow decides to be a woman, and crushes all the world records next month, are these people seriously fine with this scenario? This is some looney batshit crazy thinking. In what world is saying this would be unfair to women transphobic?

They cry about bullying to transgender people, but any time anyone disagrees with them they are labeled a bigot and they bully them into getting a permanent ban.

I honestly can't tell who is worse between the very far right bullies who are completely against transgender/lbgt people, or the far left bullies on resetera who attack anyone who has an opinion that differs with them. The two sides are more similar than they would like to believe.
oh, please link me to this fucking nonsense!
 
oh, please link me to this fucking nonsense!
And yeah, they are exactly the the same as those people. They are monsters and bullies pretending to be good guys. It's exactly the same as Karen Energy, They just believe in different forms of hate. Ive seen them justify even death threats against JKR, while blaming her for the sad state of their sorry lives.

And to be clear, most Trans people are perfectly personable. This is a minority of that minority that congregates on twitter and safe spaces like Era, while being the worst kind of people, and settimng the rest of their group back decades in the public eye. Like people are fed up with these extremists, left and right,
 

Unrivaled18

Neo Member
And yeah, they are exactly the the same as those people. They are monsters and bullies pretending to be good guys. It's exactly the same as Karen Energy, They just believe in different forms of hate. Ive seen them justify even death threats against JKR, while blaming her for the sad state of their sorry lives.

And to be clear, most Trans people are perfectly personable. This is a minority of that minority that congregates on twitter and safe spaces like Era, while being the worst kind of people, and settimng the rest of their group back decades in the public eye. Like people are fed up with these extremists, left and right,
My cousin is transgender, so I know some of the things these people have to deal with. It's sad that a lot of people will never accept them, I think we should be accepting of people and not be hateful.

That being said this same cousin is buying Hogwarts, doesn't believe trans athletes should be able to compete as there are clear differences still, and also says resetera is nuts when I shared the Harry Potter thread.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom