• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

IGN: 10 Most Terrifying Scares in Video Games

IbizaPocholo

NeoGAFs Kent Brockman


Video games have the unique ability to put you in the shoes of someone else, which also means they have the ability to scare the crap out of you like no other medium. Here's our list of the top 10 most terrifying scares in games.
 

Vawn

Banned
74183_4_xbox-rolls-with-the-punches-embraces-halo-craig-meme-as-new-mascot.jpg
 

kingpotato

Ask me about my Stream Deck
Really hate these threads when OP doesn't have a spoiler tagged tldr list. It makes me feel like the person rushed to post it for some notoriety instead of any opinion they might have on the content.

OP do you agree with the list? Youtube already serves up recommendations, so is there anything of note you wanted to highlight it for?
 

Vawn

Banned
Really hate these threads when OP doesn't have a spoiler tagged tldr list. It makes me feel like the person rushed to post it for some notoriety instead of any opinion they might have on the content.

OP do you agree with the list? Youtube already serves up recommendations, so is there anything of note you wanted to highlight it for?

Look who posted it. He doesn't usually commentate on the threads. He posts articles he reads on other sites.
 

Orta

Banned
Can't be arsed watching but number 1 isn't that stupid fucking dogs through the window bit in RE1 bit, AGAIN, is it?
 
Last edited:
Really hate these threads when OP doesn't have a spoiler tagged tldr list. It makes me feel like the person rushed to post it for some notoriety instead of any opinion they might have on the content.

OP do you agree with the list? Youtube already serves up recommendations, so is there anything of note you wanted to highlight it for?
Yeah I’m watching something I cba watching a video post the list
 

Roni

Member
The bigger news for me is that I just realized it's been 6 years since Alien Isolation came out already. Damn... Time is flying by.
 

SinDelta

Member
Top 9 for me -

1 - Return to the Ishimura - Dead Space 2

2 - The Ladder - F.E.A.R

3 - Getting pulled into the vents - Dead Space

4 - The School - Dead Space 2

5 - The Bunker - Uncharted

6 - Derelict Reaper - Mass Effect 2

7 - The Deep Roads - Dragon Age Origins

8 - Proving Grounds/Fort Frolic - Bioshock

9 - Gotham Museum - Arkham City
 
Last edited:

Oppoi

Banned
That tall legged black man with the shiny skin on the space station. You know the long head two faced creep that stalks you no matter where you go and bleed acid. Shit made me scream out loud when it first had me boxed in...
 
Last edited:

MiguelItUp

Member
Strange list. Some good mentions, but definitely some good things missing IMO.

I was both confused and surprised Tomb Raider was on the list. Odd choice. I mean, as a kiddo it was slightly startling, but I was more freaked out by all the weird shit at the end of the game, lol.
 
Last edited:
Top 9 -

1 - Return to the Ishimura - Dead Space 2

2 - The Ladder - F.E.A.R

3 - Getting pulled into the vents - Dead Space

4 - The School - Dead Space 2

5 - The Bunker - Uncharted

6 - Derelict Reaper - Mass Effect 2

7 - The Deep Roads - Dragon Age Origins

8 - Proving Grounds/Fort Frolic - Bioshock

9 - Gotham Museum - Arkham City
Man of Culture GIF for the No. 1 🤝
 

kunonabi

Member
Top 9 -

1 - Return to the Ishimura - Dead Space 2

2 - The Ladder - F.E.A.R

3 - Getting pulled into the vents - Dead Space

4 - The School - Dead Space 2

5 - The Bunker - Uncharted

6 - Derelict Reaper - Mass Effect 2

7 - The Deep Roads - Dragon Age Origins

8 - Proving Grounds/Fort Frolic - Bioshock

9 - Gotham Museum - Arkham City
...This may be the worst IGN list ever.
 

SinDelta

Member
...This may be the worst IGN list ever.
My opinion. Closest to the horror genre I get is when it overlaps with what I play. I don't go out of my way to play full throttle horror games like Amnesia The Dark Descent or Silent Hill.

That is not to say I would not be looking forward to Dead Space 4 if it ever gets made.
 
Last edited:

NewYork214

Member
Condemned is not on the list, this list is not valid.
Fuck that pussy list.

Condemned was so damn good. Would love a good remaster. Definitely in my top 5 scariest games.

Not going to lie, the first zombie in RE scared me.

Nostalgia of that scene alone makes me scared when I replay resident evil lol. I am a huge horror fan in general. The first RE was the game that hooked me into this hobby. I was only like 5 when it came out and beat it with my GameShark lol.
 

EL BABE

Neo Member
Top 9 for me -

1 - Return to the Ishimura - Dead Space 2

2 - The Ladder - F.E.A.R

3 - Getting pulled into the vents - Dead Space

4 - The School - Dead Space 2

5 - The Bunker - Uncharted

6 - Derelict Reaper - Mass Effect 2

7 - The Deep Roads - Dragon Age Origins

8 - Proving Grounds/Fort Frolic - Bioshock

9 - Gotham Museum - Arkham City
Holly hell that return to the Ishimura, I had ptsd just thinking of going back to that ship.
 

Federror

Neo Member
Growing up, I actually found Tomb Raider game scarier than say, Resident Evil. I dunno, the early games just something about the early games' atmosphere that made me nervous every so often -- the sense of isolation, the occasional and eerie ambient noises and music. I used

And then there's the butler.
 
I remember being scared by the first Dino Crisis when I was a youngster. Being stalked and hunted by dinosaurs just petrified me. Actually, my first horror was playing the original Alone in the Dark with my father, whenever it first came out.
 
Last edited:

Tiamat2san

Member
Both Condemned games are great in terms of scaring the player. My two favorites are an enemy jumping out of the closet and the bear level.
Yeah the guy in the locker!
I was so into the game , I almost had an heart attack.
Mannequins in the department store were scary too.
And the fucking bear....very impressive.
I still think there’s too much guns in the second game though .
 

kingpotato

Ask me about my Stream Deck
Tomb Raider and F.E.A.R.? Are you kidding me?!?
Tomb Raider is on the list? Is this some joke?
Strange list. Some good mentions, but definitely some good things missing IMO.

I was both confused and surprised Tomb Raider was on the list. Odd choice. I mean, as a kiddo it was slightly startling, but I was more freaked out by all the weird shit at the end of the game, lol.
I actually had a serious scare from Tomb Raider on Saturn, but it wasn't the t-rex, it was the first time you encounter a gorilla. The thing shuffles around a medium sized two tier room mostly silent. And then it grunted at me as it was rushing me from behind AHHHHH LOL.

The t-rex wasn't scary at all because they had pictures of it on the box and they telegraphed it coming so it wasn't as intense a moment.

Top 9 for me -

1 - Return to the Ishimura - Dead Space 2

2 - The Ladder - F.E.A.R

3 - Getting pulled into the vents - Dead Space

4 - The School - Dead Space 2

5 - The Bunker - Uncharted

6 - Derelict Reaper - Mass Effect 2

7 - The Deep Roads - Dragon Age Origins

8 - Proving Grounds/Fort Frolic - Bioshock

9 - Gotham Museum - Arkham City
What about your personal number 9 was scary? I just replayed this and am struggling to think what might be scary. Possibly the shark?

...This may be the worst IGN list ever.
They have a different list, this one is someone's personal opinion. IGN's list is

10. Tomb Raider T-rex
9. Half Life 2 Ravenholm
8. Silent Hill 3 Mirror
7. FEAR Ladder
6. Dead Space Broken Vent
5. Silent Hill Alley
4. Alien Isolation PS4 mic
3. Resident Evil 2 First Licker
2. Resident Evil Windows
1. P.T. Lisa
 
Last edited:

kunonabi

Member
I actually had a serious scare from Tomb Raider on Saturn, but it wasn't the t-rex, it was the first time you encounter a gorilla. The thing shuffles around a medium sized two tier room mostly silent. And then it grunted at me as it was rushing me from behind AHHHHH LOL.

The t-rex wasn't scary at all because they had pictures of it on the box and they telegraphed it coming so it wasn't as intense a moment.


What about your personal number 9 was scary? I just replayed this and am struggling to think what might be scary. Possibly the shark?


They have a different list, this one is someone's personal opinion. IGN's list is

10. Tomb Raider T-rex
9. Half Life 2 Ravenholm
8. Silent Hill 3 Mirror
7. FEAR Ladder
6. Dead Space Broken Vent
5. Silent Hill Alley
4. Alien Isolation PS4 mic
3. Resident Evil 2 First Licker
2. Resident Evil Windows
1. P.T. Lisa

Ah my bad. My apologies to SinDelta, as a personal list its solid.

Ign's list is safe with a couple questionable pics but not supremely bad. That said, as completely terrible as Silent Hill 4 is the giant head scene should be on the list.
 
Top Bottom