• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Russia begins Invasion of Ukraine

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sakura

Member
What insight are you basing that on in this war? Read of them retreating and moving troops to the Donbas a few months ago. Is that what you're referring to?

Or, maybe the Moskva being sunk?

Snake Island?
I'm not really sure what you mean. Russia has a limited amount of manpower in Ukraine. They need to take pauses after engaging in offensive operations.
Just google Russian operational pause and you will find a million articles stating they started one on the 8th or so. This isn't my insight, just what all the analysists say.
 

Kraz

Banned
I'm not really sure what you mean. Russia has a limited amount of manpower in Ukraine. They need to take pauses after engaging in offensive operations.
Just google Russian operational pause and you will find a million articles stating they started one on the 8th or so. This isn't my insight, just what all the analysists say.
The analysts also said at the start of the war it would be over in 3 days. According to some I just wasn't reading the right ones apparently. What's really bizarre to some is that I was forming my own opinion.

You specifically called it a pause "after a big advancement" implies it was intentional and not forced. What big advancement are you talking about? There hasn't been one since the start of the war. Since then it's been Ukraine continually pushing them back with Russia sustaining massive losses in forces and positions from their initial push.

They're looking to Iran for arms supplies and suing their own systems makers.

A pause in forward movement doesn't mean letting up on the enemy. Even if it was an intentional pause, there would be a need to keep artillery on Ukraine during the pause to keep them unbalanced. It's not a ceasefire.
 

Sakura

Member
The analysts also said at the start of the war it would be over in 3 days. According to some I just wasn't reading the right ones apparently. What's really bizarre to some is that I was forming my own opinion.

You specifically called it a pause "after a big advancement" implies it was intentional and not forced. What big advancement are you talking about? There hasn't been one since the start of the war. Since then it's been Ukraine continually pushing them back with Russia sustaining massive losses in forces and positions from their initial push.

They're looking to Iran for arms supplies and suing their own systems makers.

A pause in forward movement doesn't mean letting up on the enemy. Even if it was an intentional pause, there would be a need to keep artillery on Ukraine during the pause to keep them unbalanced. It's not a ceasefire.
They recently took Luhansk which is what I mean by big advancement.
They also took pauses for example after the Popasna breakthrough, but these were generally localised.
I'm not sure what you mean by intentional vs forced. It is intentional in the sense that they know they need to take a pause, and announced they would be taking one. It is also forced because the manpower issues are creating the need in the first place.
Yes they are going to need to keep artillery shelling (which they are) but it will be more limited compared to offensive pushes.
Furthermore, on Ukraine's side, an operational pause is a situation to take advantage of, which is part of the reason we see bigger pushes from Ukraine currently. Strike while your enemy is weak and all that.
 

Kraz

Banned
They recently took Luhansk which is what I mean by big advancement.
They also took pauses for example after the Popasna breakthrough, but these were generally localised.
I'm not sure what you mean by intentional vs forced. It is intentional in the sense that they know they need to take a pause, and announced they would be taking one. It is also forced because the manpower issues are creating the need in the first place.
Yes they are going to need to keep artillery shelling (which they are) but it will be more limited compared to offensive pushes.
Furthermore, on Ukraine's side, an operational pause is a situation to take advantage of, which is part of the reason we see bigger pushes from Ukraine currently. Strike while your enemy is weak and all that.
That this pause wasn't planned for by Russia is what I meant by intentional. It was forced upon them by circumstance.
This wasn't according to their design after a big advancement.

Russia announced they were taking a pause and you find that believable and the reasons they give for it? You think Russia controls the pace of the war? You think they'll be allowed to pause?

Russia got shit kicked on their advance and went as far as they can go. This possibly isn't a pause, it's the tipping point in the war where Ukraine pushing them out.
 

Sakura

Member
That this pause wasn't planned for by Russia is what I meant by intentional. It was forced upon them by circumstance.
This wasn't according to their design after a big advancement.

Russia announced they were taking a pause and you find that believable and the reasons they give for it? You think Russia controls the pace of the war? You think they'll be allowed to pause?

Russia got shit kicked on their advance and went as far as they can go. This possibly isn't a pause, it's the tipping point in the war where Ukraine pushing them out.
The Russian reason given for the pause is that their troops just need some rest, and time to get letters from home and stuff. I obviously don't believe that, and that is not the reason I said they were taking the pause for.
I'm not really sure why you are being so aggressive here. Nothing I said is controversial, and I never said the things you are asking.
 

Kraz

Banned
The Russian reason given for the pause is that their troops just need some rest, and time to get letters from home and stuff. I obviously don't believe that, and that is not the reason I said they were taking the pause for.
I'm not really sure why you are being so aggressive here. Nothing I said is controversial, and I never said the things you are asking.
Yeah they take an operational pause after every big advancement.
Though it sounds like they might be starting to move again.
You said it was after a big advancement. I was curious what you meant and how you got to that.

Today's missile strike would suggest there isn't any sort of pause/reduction in artillery strikes that was planned. More likely it's the depots being hit was original point of discussion.
 
Last edited:

Kraz

Banned
9n69yfaewmb91.jpg

…can you see the sunlit princess…
she moves softly…across the fields..
..she moves with the nature around her…every year… She greets her beloved lavender field..
a cherished friend…a memory…i know it will never fade..
… giving her more than money could buy ….
…. a memory forever…
.. i watch her stand and let a butterfly alight upon her precious finger…
…….ooh my love that memory of things like this more precious than a diamond on your finger…
the wind always blows her way…she always stares with wider eyes…
every year she grows… the more she loves the wonder…
this lavender field a memory to complete. her…remind her life is precious.. the only thing more precious….
Her amazing… lavender princess..
 

Ozriel

M$FT
After seeing those horrific videos, I think all gloves should come off and Ukraine should be given all the weapons they need.

Give them capability to strike the docks At Sevastopol. That’s where the subs hide to fire their missiles at civilian targets. More anti-ship and anti-sub equipment needed.

This constant fear of escalation is silly. Putin doesn’t want full mobilization. He knows his support will waver if Muscovites start getting shoved into the war. There’s only so much they can press-gang from the outer provinces
 

MidGenRefresh

*Refreshes biennially
I believe this is missile related only, not total artillery strikes. A map with artillery would be way more red than that. And another point would be that denying their supplies now would delay another future big scale offensive. Their logistics isn't that flexible.

I'm not getting into politics, but this pure gold:


Comments section is pure comedy gold. Oh the irony.

sLQPauJ.png
 
Last edited:

Kraz

Banned
Comments section is pure comedy gold. Oh the irony.

sLQPauJ.png
Yes. it's so funny hahahaha hahahaha hahahahaha hah ahaha
Only 4 years old.
And the irony is so clear...so clear...
Ok, maybe not,
.... whatever thing you are referring to can't even be inferred from the information provided.

What has this to do with Ukraine and what's the irony... other than making it obvious that the statement was political after saying it was made not to make this political?
 
Last edited:

MidGenRefresh

*Refreshes biennially
Yes. it's so funny hahahaha hahahaha hahahahaha hah ahaha
Only 4 years old.
And the irony is so clear...so clear...
Ok, maybe not,
.... whatever thing you are referring to can't even be inferred from the information provided.

What has this to do with Ukraine and what's the irony... other than making it obvious that the statement was political after saying it was made not to make this political?

What a reaction. :messenger_grinning_sweat: Forgot your pills today, mister? Relax. I'm sorry that you don't get it.
 

Tams

Member
Yes. it's so funny hahahaha hahahaha hahahahaha hah ahaha
Only 4 years old.
And the irony is so clear...so clear...
Ok, maybe not,
.... whatever thing you are referring to can't even be inferred from the information provided.

What has this to do with Ukraine and what's the irony... other than making it obvious that the statement was political after saying it was made not to make this political?
If you can't see how this is connected to Ukraine, then you are too dumb to be participating in this thread.
 

Kraz

Banned
If you can't see how this is connected to Ukraine, then you are too dumb to be participating in this thread.
The original comment about the energy is relevant.

The twitter comment being pointed out in the post is what was being asked about. Perhaps you can explain how that deals with Ukraine then.
 
Last edited:

Kraz

Banned
No but it makes you look like an impulsive keyboard warrior when you hammer back to back to back responses without bothering to utilize the forum tools made available to you.

Which makes it hard to take you seriously.
Strange that this comes to your attention and is worth noting for you after this single event with multiple responses from different posters coming quickly.

Perhaps you perceive more of a trend due to some personal bias that you want to read into it.

Regardless, thank you ever so kindly for sharing your genuine concern about how my posts are read by you.
 
Last edited:

Nobody_Important

“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
Strange that this comes to your attention and is worth noting for you after this single event with multiple responses from different posters coming quickly.

Perhaps you perceive more of a trend due to some personal bias that you want to read into it.

Regardless, thank you ever so kindly for sharing your genuine concern about how my posts are read by you.
Thanks for proving my point.
 
Yes. it's so funny hahahaha hahahaha hahahahaha hah ahaha
Only 4 years old.
And the irony is so clear...so clear...
Ok, maybe not,
.... whatever thing you are referring to can't even be inferred from the information provided.

What has this to do with Ukraine and what's the irony... other than making it obvious that the statement was political after saying it was made not to make this political?
Didn't you just laugh yourself at that video in post https://www.neogaf.com/threads/russia-begins-invasion-of-ukraine.1630982/post-266379392 ?
 

Kraz

Banned
The original post there was relevant, relates to energy and makes easy sense. It's the US position put forward by their intelligence and such for use by whoever is in office.

What I was asking about was regarding a later post highlighting a comment in a tweet related to it.
There isn't a clear connection with Ukraine and I was genuinely curious and annoyed. Those aren't exclusive to each other. Still haven't gotten an answer, btw.
 
Last edited:

Nobody_Important

“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
When was the last page you commented in this thread about the actual topic?
I probably have more posts in this thread in any given month at the beginning of this mess than since you started posting in here that is for sure. i have at least a hundred posts in this thread. The fact I called you out for your behavior doesn't mean I don't care about the topic. Quite the opposite.


Though I will give you credit for the attempted dodge. A for effort.
 
Last edited:

Kraz

Banned
I probably have more posts in this thread in any given month at the beginning of this mess than since you started posting in here that is for sure. i have at least a hundred posts in this thread. The fact I called you out for your behavior doesn't mean I don't care about the topic. Quite the opposite.


Though I will give you credit for the attempted dodge. A for effort.
Take a look at page 1.
 

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
Makes it funnier that Russian state TV claims to have installed him.



Some people don't care about self-contraction however. They'll claim one thing at first and do the exact opposite the next.




But yeah there is very little consistency in their messaging, because they don't care about that, their lies lands better when people are confused.
 

winjer

Member
Trump using this as a campaign slogan, might push other Republicans to up the ante. And even force Democrats to escalate the issue.
If US politics gets focused on the idea of destroying Russia, this could escalate to dangerous levels.
Russia might be a joke as a conventional military force, but they do have a lot of nukes.
I hope we don't get to the point of another Cuban missile stalemate, with both sides ready to press the "red button".
 

Kraz

Banned
Trump using this as a campaign slogan, might push other Republicans to up the ante. And even force Democrats to escalate the issue.
If US politics gets focused on the idea of destroying Russia, this could escalate to dangerous levels.
Russia might be a joke as a conventional military force, but they do have a lot of nukes.
I hope we don't get to the point of another Cuban missile stalemate, with both sides ready to press the "red button".
The way to sort this out for Ukraine is that they don't want to destroy Russia. They want them out and held accountable at the Hague. The latter for whatever that means, but that's for later. Get them out first.
There's no plans to destroy from Ukraine or other Nato nations.
 
D

Deleted member 1159

Unconfirmed Member

This just goes to show stupid it is when people complain about how long timelines are and how expensive things can be to develop in the west while the Chinese or Russians slap some shit together and say “da, is good!” …until it’s fucking game time and your building which took two days to build with no inspections collapses or your weapon system proves to be totally ineffective
 

Chittagong

Gold Member
This just goes to show stupid it is when people complain about how long timelines are and how expensive things can be to develop in the west while the Chinese or Russians slap some shit together and say “da, is good!” …until it’s fucking game time and your building which took two days to build with no inspections collapses or your weapon system proves to be totally ineffective

To be fair, the Russian Buk-M1 missile system has been proven in combat to be extremely effective in downing mid-to-large bodied civilian aircraft
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom