Prototype-03 said:
Noel is WIDE open if she doesn't connect her drive. I don't know what the problem is. She DOES have a combo that takes 40-50% damage, but so do most characters. If I play it right, I can deal OVER 50% with Rachel. I mean, there are tweaks that everybody needs, but the FIRST ones to be tweaked should be Nu and Tager, and then Arakune and Rachel (sadly).
Maybe I've still got things to learn, but like I said...if I use a strong mid-air kick with bang right towards her head it shouldn't just fly right through it. It doesn't look good, and it doesn't play good. I don't have a HUGE problem with that though. The damage is just a wee bit much. I can definitely see 40-50% damage with Rachel, Jin, Ragna, Tager, Hakumen, but it feels a bit ridiculous when Noel pulls since the drive isn't the primary combo starter. Besides Jin most of these characters need the proper conditions to pull that kind of damage(Tager can't dash, Ragna has easy punish because of low health, Hakumen is very stiff as well). Noel as far as I can see is pretty mobile, pretty strong, decent health, and a drive that leaves her open if you spam it...
Jin gives me some problems too, but that has more to do with the matchup, plus my panicky nature when I get frozen than the character itself. It is really easy to counter ice spamming Jins (a lot of start up time).
I've had more matches with Jins lately, and I've been enjoying it much more now that I'm improving. Besides the vertical slash, and the abundant Ice moves, I've got no major complaints, and I've had a lot more fun with him.
Carl needs everything he has to do well, so I'm fine with the clap trap.
An INFINITE clap trap is RIDICULOUS. I've got no problem with him having a three hit, or three grab limit in the trap though. The player can attempt it that way as many times as he/she likes, and it is MUCH MORE reasonable.
@Grifter
I haven't even called her broken dude. I've got some grievances here, but they don't kill the game for me. I still play like I got no life, and I still have TONS of fun. I just feel that if there are tweaks that need to be done these are the ones that come to mind. Don't take it too personally.
:/
Edit: Just read your expanded thoughts on Carl. That's all cleared up now.